Guides

How to Sew a Button: Flat and Shank Buttons by Hand

How to Sew a Button: Flat and Shank Buttons by Hand

A missing button is one of the most common reasons good clothes end up at the back of the wardrobe, and it is also one of the quickest repairs you can learn: a needle, some thread and ten minutes.

Learning how to sew a button by hand keeps shirts, coats and trousers in rotation and makes thrifted finds with one loose button an easy buy. This guide follows the American Sewing Guild’s guideline on attaching buttons for the core technique, then fills in the practical details for shirts, pants and coats. It sits alongside our other small care fixes, such as How to Remove Pilling From Clothes (and Stop It Coming Back), that keep clothes looking good for longer.

Types of buttons

Before you start, look at the button. There are two main kinds, and they are attached differently.

  • Sew-through (flat) buttons have two or four holes through the button itself. Shirts, blouses and most trousers use these.
  • Shank buttons have a solid face and a small loop or stem (the shank) on the back. The thread goes through the shank, not the face. Coats, blazers and decorative buttons often use these.

Flat buttons on thicker fabrics, such as coats and jackets, are often given a thread shank: a short stem of wrapped thread that lifts the button off the fabric so it can sit on top of the buttonhole layer. Instructions for all three are below.

What you need

  • The button. Many shirts and coats come with a spare sewn inside the front placket, the side seam or the care label. Check there first.
  • A hand-sewing needle with an eye big enough for a double strand of thread.
  • Thread matching the other buttons’ thread, not just the fabric. All-purpose polyester thread works for most clothing.
  • Scissors or snips.
  • A toothpick or a large needle for spacing a thread shank.
  • Pins or chalk to mark the button position.
  • A thimble (optional) to push the needle through thick fabric.

If you are starting from nothing, a small Sewing Kit With Needles Thread And Buttons on Amazon covers everything above and is handy to keep in a drawer or suitcase.

Before you sew: marking the spot

  1. Pull out any loose threads left from the old button.
  2. Look for the original holes in the fabric. These show exactly where the button sat.
  3. If there are no marks, button up the garment and push a pin through the buttonhole into the fabric underneath.
  4. Mark the pin point with chalk or leave the pin in place as your guide.

The American Sewing Guild notes that buttons traditionally sit on the left front of women’s garments and the right front of men’s. That is worth knowing if you are replacing a whole set or moving buttons on a garment you are altering.

How to sew a flat button (2-hole or 4-hole)

These steps follow the American Sewing Guild’s guidance on sew-through buttons: a double strand of thread knotted at the ends, starting from the wrong side, with each pair of holes stitched at least twice, and more if the button will see rugged wear.

  1. Cut a length of thread roughly the length of your arm.
  2. Thread the needle and pull the thread through until both ends are even.
  3. Knot the two ends together so you are sewing with a double strand.
  4. From the wrong side (inside) of the fabric, push the needle up through the marked spot.
  5. Thread the button onto the needle through one hole and slide it down to the fabric.
  6. Push the needle down through the opposite hole (for a 2-hole button) or the hole beside it (for a 4-hole button) and through the fabric.
  7. Come back up through the first hole and repeat, sewing through the same pair of holes at least twice, more for buttons that take strain.
  8. For a 4-hole button, move to the second pair of holes and repeat.
  9. Finish with the needle on the wrong side of the fabric.
  10. Make two or three small stitches through the thread on the back, then knot and trim the ends.

Parallel bars or an X?

On a 4-hole button, a common method is to sew two parallel bars (two separate pairs of holes) or an X (crossing diagonally). Both hold well. Matching the pattern of the other buttons keeps a shirt looking consistent.

How to make a thread shank

On coats, jackets and other thick fabrics, a flat button sewn tight against the fabric leaves no room for the buttonhole layer. A thread shank fixes this. The American Sewing Guild describes the method this way: stitch over a spacer, then wrap the stitches, which protects the threads from abrasion and helps stop the button falling off easily.

  1. Start as for a flat button, with a knotted double strand coming up from the wrong side.
  2. Lay a toothpick or large needle across the top of the button, between the holes.
  3. Stitch through the holes and over the toothpick, so the stitches pass over it.
  4. Repeat the stitches through each pair of holes.
  5. Remove the toothpick. The button now sits loose on a few millimetres of thread.
  6. Bring the needle up between the button and the fabric, without going through the button.
  7. Wind the thread tightly around the stitches under the button several times to form a firm stem.
  8. Push the needle to the wrong side and knot the thread securely.

For very thick coats, a thicker spacer (such as a matchstick) makes a longer shank. Match the shank length roughly to the thickness of the fabric around the buttonhole.

How to sew a shank button

Shank buttons already have their own stem, so you do not need a spacer. The American Sewing Guild describes stitching from the wrong side through the shank and back several times, then knotting on the wrong side.

  1. Thread the needle with a knotted double strand.
  2. Bring the needle up from the wrong side at the marked spot.
  3. Pass the needle through the shank loop.
  4. Push the needle back down through the fabric close to where it came up.
  5. Repeat several times, keeping the shank lined up with the direction of the buttonhole.
  6. Finish on the wrong side with a few small stitches and a knot.

Sew a button on a shirt

Shirt buttons are usually small 2- or 4-hole buttons, and shirts often have a spare sewn in near the bottom of the front placket or on the care label. A few practical notes:

  • Use thread that matches the other buttons, usually white, cream or a colour matched to the button.
  • Keep the stitches a little loose rather than tight on a dress shirt, so the button has room to pass through the buttonhole.
  • For the collar button, pull the fabric gently flat while sewing, since collars are stiff and double-layered.
  • Cuff buttons take a lot of wear. Add an extra pass of stitching through each pair of holes.

For a full set of fresh buttons on an older shirt, a mixed pack of Replacement Shirt Buttons Assorted on Amazon makes it easy to match size and colour. Our guides to Mens Dress Shirts and White Shirt Outfits cover what to do with the shirt once it is back in action, and How to Iron a Shirt in 7 Steps covers pressing the placket around a new button.

Sew a button on pants

Trouser and jean waist buttons take far more strain than shirt buttons. The American Sewing Guild’s guidance to add more stitches where rugged wear is expected applies here.

  • Use a strong all-purpose or heavy-duty thread.
  • Stitch through each pair of holes several more times than you would on a shirt.
  • Add a short thread shank on thick waistbands so the button sits comfortably through the buttonhole.
  • Many jeans use a metal tack button that is hammered on, not sewn. A replacement usually needs a no-sew tack button kit rather than thread.

If the waist button keeps popping, the waistband may be under too much tension. Check the fit using our How to Measure Your Waist for Clothing Sizes guide, and if the pants are also too long, How to Hem Pants covers the next easy fix.

Common mistakes

  • Pulling the stitches too tight. A button pressed flat against the fabric is hard to fasten and wears the thread faster.
  • Too few passes. Two passes per pair of holes is the American Sewing Guild minimum; add more for coats and waistbands.
  • Skipping the knot on the back. Finish with small locking stitches and a knot on the wrong side.
  • Mismatched thread. Match the thread on the other buttons, not just the fabric colour.
  • Wrong position. Mark through the buttonhole before you sew, or the garment will pucker when fastened.

Care and maintenance

A few habits keep buttons on longer:

  • Unbutton shirts fully before putting them on or taking them off over your head.
  • Check buttons when you do laundry, and secure loose ones before they fall off.
  • Turn shirts with delicate buttons inside out before washing.
  • Keep spare buttons in a small jar or envelope labelled with the garment.

These fixes are part of what makes secondhand shopping work: a coat with a missing button is often priced lower, and a ten-minute repair brings it right back. Our guide to How to Find Vintage Clothing covers other small flaws that are easy to fix and worth looking past.

Frequently asked questions

How many times should I stitch through a button?

The American Sewing Guild suggests stitching through each pair of holes at least twice, and more if the button will see rugged wear, such as on coats and trouser waistbands.

Should I use single or double thread?

The American Sewing Guild describes using a double strand knotted at the ends for sew-through buttons. It is stronger and quicker than a single strand.

What is a thread shank and when do I need one?

A thread shank is a short stem of wrapped thread between a flat button and the fabric. It gives the buttonhole layer room to sit under the button. It is commonly used on coats, jackets and other thick fabrics.

How do I sew a shank button?

Stitch from the wrong side through the shank loop and back down several times, then knot on the wrong side. No spacer is needed because the button already has a shank.

Which side do buttons go on?

According to the American Sewing Guild, buttons traditionally sit on the left front of women’s garments and the right front of men’s.

Can I sew a button without a needle threader?

Yes. Cut the thread end cleanly at an angle, moisten it slightly and push it through the needle’s eye. A needle with a larger eye also helps.

Shop the look on Amazon

Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.

Browse picks on Amazon →

Sewing Glossaries

Stitches, seams, hems and buttons.

Glossaries


More Repairs & Alterations

Zippers and dresses.

Guides