Buttons are small, but they decide how a garment closes, how it looks and how easy it is to repair, so it helps to know which kind you are holding.
This guide covers the main types of buttons: flat sew-through and shank buttons, plus covered, toggle, stud and novelty styles, along with common button materials and what to check on thrifted pieces. When a button comes loose, our How to Sew a Button guide shows the full method for each type.
According to the Online Etymology Dictionary, “button” dates from around 1300, meaning a “knob or ball attached to another body”, especially one “passed through a slit or loop” to hold a garment together, from Old French boton, “bud”. “Buttonhole” follows in the 1560s. Wikipedia’s button article says the earliest known button, found at Mohenjo-daro in the Indus Valley, is made of curved shell and is about 5,000 years old, and that buttons were “originally used more as an ornament than as a fastening.” Buttonholes for fastening clothing, according to most histories, first appeared in 13th-century Germany.
Button types at a glance
| Button | Key feature | Typically found on |
|---|---|---|
| Flat two-hole | Two holes through the face | Shirts, blouses |
| Flat four-hole | Four holes, sewn in bars or an X | Shirts, trousers, coats |
| Shank button | Loop or stem on the back | Coats, blazers, cardigans |
| Covered button | Wrapped in fabric | Dresses, dinner jackets |
| Toggle | Bar-shaped, through a loop | Duffle coats, knitwear |
| Jeans (tack) button | Fixed by a metal tack | Jeans, denim jackets |
| Snap | Two parts pressed together | Western shirts, baby clothes |
| Ball or novelty button | Decorative shape | Vintage blouses, cardigans |
Shank vs flat button
Flat (sew-through) buttons
Wikipedia describes flat or sew-through buttons as having “holes through which thread is sewn”. They come with two or four holes. Spot it: holes visible through the front. The American Sewing Guild’s guideline on attaching buttons recommends a double strand of thread knotted at the ends, coming up from the wrong side, and stitching through each pair of holes at least twice, “more if rugged wear is expected”. Sewing four-hole buttons in parallel bars or an X is a common method.
The same guideline describes a thread shank for flat buttons on thick fabric: lay a toothpick or large needle across the button, stitch over it, remove it, bring the needle up between button and fabric, wind the thread around the stitches several times and knot. Sewing.org says this “protects the threads from abrasion, and prevents the button from falling off easily.”
Shank buttons
Per Wikipedia, shank buttons have “a hollow protrusion on the back through which thread is sewn”. The face has no holes. Spot it: a smooth front and a loop or stem behind. The American Sewing Guild says to stitch from the wrong side through the shank and back several times, then knot on the wrong side. Shanks leave room for thick fabric, which is why they are common on coats and Types of Jackets.
Other types of buttons
Covered buttons
Buttons wrapped in fabric to match or contrast with the garment. Debrett’s lists covered buttons on the black-tie dinner jacket; see Types of Suits. Thrift note: check for worn fabric showing the form underneath.
Toggles
A commonly used name for bar-shaped buttons, often wood or horn, that pass through a loop rather than a buttonhole. Common on duffle coats and chunky knits.
Jeans buttons and snaps
Jeans buttons are commonly fixed with a metal tack instead of thread, and snaps press two halves together. Both need tools to replace, so check them before buying denim or Western shirts.
Button-down collar buttons
Small buttons that fasten collar points to the shirt. The V&A holds a plaid button-down shirt made in Great Britain around 1972. See Button-Up vs Button-Down and Types of Shirt Collars.
Ball or novelty buttons
A commonly used label for buttons shaped as balls, flowers, animals or other motifs. They turn up often on vintage blouses, children’s wear and Types of Cardigans. Spot it: a decorative shape, usually with a shank behind. Thrift note: novelty buttons are hard to replace one at a time, so a single missing one may mean swapping the full set.
How to spot a quality button
There is no single official test, but a few common cues help when you are comparing pieces on a rack:
- Secure stitching. Thread that is tight, even and wound into a short shank on thicker fabric holds up better than a few loose passes.
- Clean edges. Chips, cracks or rough edges on the button can snag knits and wear through buttonholes.
- Matching sets. A mismatched button usually means an earlier replacement, which is fine, but worth noting if the piece is vintage.
- Buttonhole fit. The button should pass through without forcing; a stretched or frayed buttonhole is a repair to price in.
Button materials
Wikipedia notes modern buttons are “commonly made of plastic but also may be made of metal, wood, or seashell”, and lists historical materials including vegetable ivory, bone, horn, brass, pewter, porcelain and enamel. On vintage pieces, unusual materials can be part of the appeal, so replacing them is a choice to make carefully.
Sewing.org also notes that buttons traditionally sit on the left front of women’s garments and the right front of men’s.
Checking buttons when thrifting
- Count the buttons and look for any missing.
- Check the spare-button pocket inside coats or on the care label.
- Tug each button gently to test the thread.
- Look at buttonholes for fraying.
- Check that metal buttons are free of corrosion.
These are common checks, not an official standard. A missing button is usually an easy fix: an Assorted Sewing Buttons on Amazon set and a Hand Sewing Kit on Amazon cover most repairs. For the stitches used, see Types of Stitches.
Top-selling match on Amazon
- Versatile Fabric Compatibility: Works on denim, cotton, polyester, and canvas – from shirts and dresses to coats…
Top-selling match on Amazon
- Package Includes: 300 Pieces of resin buttons, the diameter of this pack of buttons 5/8" (15mm) SMALL…
- Quality Buttons: These buttons are made of resin, the surface is smooth, waterproof and durable, can…
- Wide Applications: They can be applied as replacement for kid's shirt, suitable for fine motor…
Types of buttons FAQ
What is the difference between a shank and a flat button?
A flat button has holes through its face; a shank button has a loop on the back and no visible holes.
Why do coats use shank buttons?
The shank leaves space for thick fabric under the button. For flat buttons on thick fabric, a thread shank does a similar job.
Can I replace all the buttons on a thrifted coat?
Yes, and it is a common way to refresh a piece. Match the size to the buttonholes; see Types of Cuffs for cuff buttons too.
How do you replace a jeans button?
Jeans buttons are fixed with a metal tack rather than thread, so replacing one usually means a replacement jeans-button kit instead of a needle. The tack is pushed through the waistband from the inside and pressed or tapped into the new button until it locks. Some kits use a screw-on back that needs no hammer. If the denim around the old hole is torn, reinforce it with a small patch before fitting the new button.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.