Guides

Monk Strap Shoes: Single vs Double and How to Wear Them

Monk Strap Shoes: Single vs Double and How to Wear Them

Swap laces for a buckle and you get one of the most distinctive dress shoes in menswear, a style that sits comfortably between a classic lace-up and a loafer.

Monk strap shoes fasten with one or two buckled straps across the instep instead of laces. They are dressy enough for a suit, relaxed enough for chinos, and they give an outfit a little more character than a plain Oxford. This guide covers single vs double monk straps, where they sit on the formality ladder, outfit pairings, colours, fit, care and what to check when buying a pair secondhand. For every other style, from Oxfords to Chelsea boots, see our hub guide to Men’s Dress Shoes.

Single vs double monk strap

Single monk strap Double monk strap
Fastening One strap and buckle Two straps and buckles
Look Cleaner, more streamlined Bolder, more of a statement
Formality Slightly dressier Slightly more fashion-forward
Best with Business suits, conservative offices Suits, blazers, chinos, flannel
Adjustability One point of adjustment Two points, so finer control over the instep

Neither is right or wrong. A single monk strap in black calf is the closer cousin to a cap-toe Oxford; a double monk strap in brown suede is a confident weekend shoe. If you are buying your first pair, a dark brown double monk strap is probably the most versatile.

How formal are monk strap dress shoes?

Monk straps sit in the middle of the formality ladder. Debrett’s lists black “highly polished or patent lace-up shoes” for black tie and white tie, so a lace-up Oxford remains the expected choice there. Below that, a plain black or dark brown monk strap in smooth leather works with most suits, at business events and at many weddings. The usual order, which is common styling advice rather than a fixed rule, places them roughly alongside brogues: below the plain Oxford and derby, above the loafer. Our Oxford vs Derby Shoes guide explains the two lace-ups that sit above them.

Material and colour shift the formality:

  • Black smooth calf: the dressiest version; fine with a charcoal or navy suit.
  • Dark brown or oxblood calf: business suits, blazers and smart trousers.
  • Tan leather: daytime and summer tailoring.
  • Suede in any colour: smart casual, chinos, flannel, dark denim.
  • Broguing or a textured toe: leans casual.

What to wear with monk strap shoes

Outfit Monk strap
Charcoal or navy suit, white shirt, tie Black or dark brown single monk, smooth leather
Grey flannel trousers, navy blazer Dark brown double monk
Chinos, Oxford-cloth shirt, knit sweater Tan or brown suede double monk
Dark jeans, button-down, unstructured jacket Brown suede double monk
Summer suit in linen or cotton Tan leather or light suede single monk

A common styling point: because the buckle is a focal point, keep the trouser hem clean. A slim, no-break or slight-break hem lets the strap show; a lot of trouser fabric pooling on top covers it. For office outfits built around shoes like these, see Business Casual for Men, and for formal suiting, Men’s Formal Wear.

Buckled or unbuckled?

Some people wear double monk straps with the top buckle undone as a deliberate, relaxed look. It is a style choice, not a requirement. It can look sloppy if the loose strap flaps, and it puts extra stress on the strap over time. If in doubt, buckle both.

Colours and pairings

The usual shoe-colour conventions apply. Black is the formal default; Debrett’s describes formal, polished black shoes for business suits under the British lounge-suit code. Brown and oxblood, in common styling advice, pair well with navy, grey and earth-tone tailoring for daytime and business. Match the belt’s leather and colour to the shoe, and consider matching the buckle metal on the shoe to your belt buckle and watch. Silver-tone buckles read cooler and dressier; brass reads warmer. If you are comparing, Mens Double Monk Strap Shoes Leather on Amazon and Mens Suede Monk Strap Shoes on Amazon show a range of styles.

Fit

The buckles make monk straps adjustable, but they do not replace good sizing. The American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society suggests getting measured at the end of the day, leaving about 3/8 to 1/2 inch beyond the longest toe and not relying on the marked size, since sizing differs by brand. Check that the strap buckles comfortably on a middle hole rather than the last one; that leaves room to adjust when your feet swell later in the day or when you wear thicker socks.

Care

Care is the same as any leather dress shoe. SATRA describes shoe trees as devices that try to preserve a shoe’s shape and prevent creases, and notes that waxes and creams are often applied to leather to improve water repellency. A few extras for monk straps:

  • Wipe the buckles with a dry cloth so polish does not build up around them.
  • Keep polish off the strap edges where it can stiffen the leather.
  • Unbuckle fully before taking the shoes off, rather than levering your heel out, to protect the back of the shoe.

A pair of cedar trees helps: search Cedar Shoe Trees Men on Amazon.

How to thrift monk strap shoes

Monk straps turn up less often than lace-ups, which makes them a satisfying find. What to check:

  • Straps and buckles: look for cracking where the strap bends, stretched buckle holes and buckles that are loose or bent.
  • Soles and heels: look for holes, thin spots at the ball of the foot and uneven heel wear.
  • Uppers: fine creases polish out; deep cracks do not.
  • Insoles: check for heavy staining or a footbed deeply moulded to someone else’s foot.
  • Labels: under the FTC Leather Guides, bonded leather should not be sold as plain “leather,” so read the label.

Our Men’s Thrift Store Shopping and How to Clean Shoes from the Thrift Store guides cover where to look and how to refresh what you find.

Frequently asked questions

Are monk strap shoes formal?

They are moderately formal. A black or dark brown monk strap in smooth leather works with most suits, but for black tie a polished black lace-up is the expected choice.

Single or double monk strap: which is better?

Neither is better. Single monks look cleaner and slightly dressier; double monks are bolder and offer two points of adjustment.

Can you wear monk straps with jeans?

Yes. Suede or textured-leather monk straps in brown pair well with dark denim and a jacket.

Should you leave a monk strap unbuckled?

It is a personal style choice. Buckling both straps looks neater and is easier on the leather.

Shop the look on Amazon

Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.

Browse picks on Amazon →