Men’s thrift stores are goldmines that most guys walk right past, and the ones who do walk in usually look in the wrong places.
Building most of a wardrobe secondhand is realistic for men, and the mens thrift store experience is different from women’s thrifting — the inventory is smaller but the quality floor is higher, because menswear uses sturdier fabrics and simpler construction that ages better. This guide, part of our Thrift and Resale Fashion affordable fashion coverage, covers exactly what to look for, what to skip, and how to make thrift store mens clothes a reliable part of your wardrobe.
What to Look for at Men’s Thrift Stores
Button-down shirts. This is the single best category in men’s thrifting. Men donate dress shirts constantly, and brands like Brooks Brothers, Ralph Lauren, and J.Crew show up regularly at Goodwill and Savers. Brooks Brothers oxford cloth shirts, which cost many times more new, regularly turn up at thrift prices. Check for collar fraying and underarm staining; everything else is usually fine. Mens Dress Shirts on Amazon
Denim. Levi’s are the perennial thrift find, and for good reason — they are donated in volume and the denim holds up through multiple owners. Look specifically for 501s and 505s in rigid or dark washes. Pre-owned denim has the advantage of already being broken in, so the fit is more comfortable from day one than stiff new jeans. A pair of Levi’s 501s at $8 from a thrift store, already softened, is a better buy than the same pair new at $60.
Outerwear and jackets. Men’s outerwear is built heavier than women’s and lasts longer secondhand. A Carhartt Detroit jacket is a classic example: expensive new, built to be essentially indestructible, and occasionally found on thrift racks. Barbour, Patagonia, and North Face jackets also appear regularly and are worth grabbing immediately when you spot them. Check zippers and snaps; everything else is repairable. For other places to buy used menswear, see our guide to second-hand clothes for men.
Wool sweaters and knits. Merino and lambswool sweaters from brands like J.Crew, Banana Republic, and Brooks Brothers thrift extremely well. Wool maintains its shape and resists odor, so a secondhand wool sweater in good condition is functionally identical to a new one. A cold-water hand wash with wool-safe detergent is usually all a thrifted merino or lambswool sweater needs to look fresh again. Always check for moth holes — hold the sweater up to the light and look for pinpricks of light through the fabric.
Leather belts. Full-grain leather belts are nearly indestructible and show up at thrift stores for $2-5. Check the buckle hardware and the belt holes — if the leather is not cracking and the holes are not stretched out, it has years of life left. The quick test: bend the belt in half gently. Full-grain leather flexes smoothly without surface cracking; bonded or faux leather shows visible creasing or flaking at the fold. Branded full-grain belts from makers like Coach are worth grabbing at thrift prices, and a good leather belt can last for years of daily wear. A quick conditioning with a leather conditioner such as Lexol brings back the sheen and suppleness of dried-out leather.
What to Skip at the Thrift Store
Underwear and socks. Obviously. But also skip undershirts and thermal base layers — these sit against the skin and absorb body oils that washing does not fully remove. Buy these new.
Fast-fashion brand clothing. H&M, Zara, and Forever 21 pieces at a thrift store are usually there because they fell apart. The fabric was thin when new and only got worse. Paying $4 for a worn-out H&M shirt is not a deal. Mens Thrift Finds on Poshmark
Suits that do not fit in the shoulders. A tailor can adjust almost everything on a suit except the shoulder width. If the shoulders do not fit at the thrift store, walk away. A $20 thrifted suit that needs $80 in alterations is a $100 suit that still might not fit right.
Leather shoes with cracked uppers. Leather shoe soles can be replaced. Scuffs can be polished out. But once the leather upper cracks, the shoe is dying. Check the flex point (where the shoe bends when walking) for deep creases or cracking. For more on thrifted shoes, check our Second Hand Shopping guide.
How to Find Mens Thrift Finds Consistently
Consistency in men’s thrift comes from three habits.
Shop regularly but quickly. A weekly stop of about 20 minutes beats an occasional three-hour session. Skip browsing: go straight to the men’s shirt section, check for known brands, flip to the pants, check the outerwear rack, and leave. Frequency matters more than time spent. The best finds get snatched within a day or two of being put on the floor. Expect uneven results: some weeks nothing, some weeks two or three items that justify the stop.
Know your measurements cold. Neck, chest, waist, inseam and shoe size are the core five. With them in your phone, you can check a garment’s tag, compare it against your numbers, and decide in seconds whether it is worth trying on. This eliminates most of the time wasted in fitting rooms. Measure yourself once and write it down.
Focus on two or three stores. Different thrift stores serve different donor bases. A Goodwill in a wealthier suburb will often carry better menswear brands than one downtown. A practical approach is to try every store within reach over a month, then narrow to the two or three with the best men’s inventory.
Online Men’s Thrift Options
If your local thrift stores disappoint, online platforms fill the gap.
Poshmark has a strong men’s section. Search by brand and size — “Brooks Brothers 16 34/35” for dress shirts, “Levi 501 34×32” for jeans — and you will find targeted results. Prices are higher than in-store thrift (typically $15-30 for shirts, $20-40 for denim) but still well below retail. Favor sellers who list accurate measurements and condition photos; those listings are the ones least likely to disappoint.
eBay remains excellent for men’s secondhand clothing, especially for specific items. For Barbour jackets, Red Wing boots, and vintage Levi’s, eBay’s selection is deeper than most other platforms. Use saved searches and set up alerts for the items you want.
ThredUp is not an option for men’s clothing: it doesn’t run a men’s clothing department (its clothing is women’s and kids’, with men’s limited to shoes). For chinos and button-downs, stick with Poshmark and eBay.
If you’d rather shop from home, see our guide to the best online men’s thrift stores.
The Verdict
Men’s thrift store shopping is one of the most efficient ways to build a quality wardrobe on a budget. Menswear is built to last, donated in volume, and priced at thrift stores as if it were all the same quality — which means a $5 Brooks Brothers non-iron pinpoint oxford sits next to a $5 Walmart George brand shirt made from tissue-thin polyester blend. The guy who knows the difference — who checks the fabric content tag, feels the weight of the cotton, and recognizes the brand — walks out with a wardrobe worth ten times what he paid. Go weekly, know your sizes, focus on natural fabrics from known brands, and skip anything fast-fashion. Within a few months, you will have a closet full of quality menswear that cost less than a single department store shopping trip.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
Browse picks on Amazon →FAQ
What are the best things to buy at men’s thrift stores?
Button-down shirts (especially Brooks Brothers, Ralph Lauren, and J.Crew), Levi’s denim, outerwear from brands like Carhartt and Patagonia, wool sweaters, and leather belts. These categories offer the biggest gap between thrift prices and retail value, and the items hold up well through multiple owners.
How do I know if thrift store clothes are good quality?
Check the fabric content tag first — wool, cotton, linen, and silk signal quality. Then check the brand. Then inspect for damage: collar fraying, underarm stains, pilling, and seam pulling. If the fabric is a quality fiber, the brand is reputable, and there is no visible damage, the piece is worth buying.
Is it weird for guys to thrift?
No. Secondhand shopping has become mainstream for all genders, and resale apps and thrift chains now actively court male shoppers. The stigma, to the extent it ever existed, is gone.
How often should I go to the thrift store?
Once a week is the sweet spot for consistently finding good pieces. Less than that and you miss inventory turnover. More than that and you start buying things you do not need. Set a time limit (20-30 minutes) and a spending limit ($20-30) per visit to stay efficient.