Pistola’s straight-leg lineup is built on three cuts: the Cassie Super High Rise Straight, the Charlie High Rise Classic Straight Ankle and the Lexi Mid Rise Bowed Straight. They are sold through Pistola’s own site and stockists such as Revolve and Anthropologie, and they sit in the premium-adjacent tier, below AGOLDE and Mother at full price.
One naming note first, because it trips up a lot of searches: the Pistola Bobbie is a high-rise wide leg, not a straight, and the Lennon is a cropped bootcut. If you want a Pistola straight, the Cassie, Charlie and Lexi are the styles to look for. Pistola’s site lists the Cassie at about $178 (with a cropped version around $168), the Charlie at about $158 and the Lexi at roughly $168 to $178, depending on wash. Pillar context is in the designer women’s denim guide.
Cassie versus Charlie versus Lexi
The Cassie Super High Rise Straight is the signature straight: a super high rise, a straight leg that is relaxed rather than slim, and a full or near-full length in most washes. The Charlie High Rise Classic Straight Ankle is the easier everyday cut: a high rise that Pistola describes as hugging the waist and hips, straight through the leg, cropped to an ankle length. The Lexi Mid Rise Bowed Straight is the trend cut: a lower mid rise and a subtly curved, bowed leg that still reads as a straight.
If you are coming from AGOLDE Riley or Mother Hustler, the Cassie is the closest Pistola comparison in rise and vintage feel. If you want a cropped straight for spring and summer, start with the Charlie. If you want the curved-leg look that sits between a straight and a barrel, the Lexi is the one.
If you have worn the Pistola Penny wide leg or the Pistola barrel, the straights come from the same brand fit logic, but compare the fabric line on each listing, since Pistola uses both rigid and stretch denims.
Real specs and fabric
Cassie: Pistola lists a 12-inch rise and a 16.5-inch leg opening. The inseam varies by wash, mostly 30 to 31 inches, with some shorter washes at 28 inches. Several Cassie washes are listed as rigid, non-stretch 100% cotton. A Petite Cassie is also sold, listed with an 11.75-inch rise and a 28-inch inseam.
Charlie: retail listings give an 11-inch rise and a cropped 27-inch inseam. Fabric varies by wash: Pistola lists 99% cotton and 1% spandex on at least one, while other versions use cotton-rayon blends. Check the composition on the specific listing.
Lexi: listings give a 10-inch rise, a 29-inch inseam and a 17.5-inch leg opening, mostly in non-stretch cotton. A petite Lexi is listed with a 27-inch inseam.
On someone around 5’7″, a 27-inch inseam like the Charlie’s lands at or just above the ankle, which is the intended cropped read, while a 31-inch Cassie reaches close to the floor with a flat shoe. Shorter shoppers should expect all three to land lower on the leg, or look at the petite versions.
The fit reality
Rigid cuts fit differently from stretch cuts. Several Cassie and Lexi listings note that the style runs large, and Pistola suggests sizing down in the Lexi for a closer fit. Rigid cotton also softens and gives a little with wear, so a pair that feels firm at the waist on day one usually relaxes. The Charlie, in its stretch versions, is the most forgiving of the three. As with any brand, check the size chart for each style, since grading can differ between cuts and washes.
The trade-off by fabric: rigid cotton holds its shape and wears in like vintage denim but takes a few wears to break in; lighter stretch and rayon blends are comfortable immediately but are more prone to pilling at the inner thigh. If a vintage-style hand is the priority, the rigid Cassie washes are the ones to look at.
Compared to the straight-leg field
At roughly $158 to $178, Pistola’s straights sit at the entry of premium-adjacent straight leg. Madewell’s straight cuts are the closest mid-tier alternative. The AGOLDE Riley is the premium step up in heavier cotton with a cropped silhouette. The Mother Hustler is the slouchier premium alternative. The Khaite Abigail is the luxury reference. Mass-market high-rise straights from Old Navy and Gap cover the budget end. Compare current stock at Pistola Cassie Straight Jeans on Amazon and Pistola Straight Leg Jeans on Amazon.
For broader category context, see the straight-leg jeans guide. If you are weighing a Pistola straight against other Pistola cuts, also see the Pistola Wes Barrel and the Pistola petite review.
Outfits that actually work
First, Cassie with a fitted white button-down half-tucked, brown leather belt and ankle boot. The classic straight-leg standard. Second, Charlie with a cropped knit in cream, gold hoops and a leather slide. Saturday morning. Third, Cassie with a fitted black turtleneck, structured blazer and square-toe boot. Office. Fourth, Lexi with a ribbed tank, a Birkenstock Boston and a structured tote. Walk-around weekend.
The cropped Charlie works with both sneakers and sandals, which makes it the most versatile in warm weather. The full-length Cassie is more boot-or-mule biased, and the Lexi’s curved leg looks best with a slightly chunky shoe that anchors the hem.
Wash and care reality
Wash any Pistola straight cold, inside out, and lay it flat to dry. Dark washes can bleed in the first few cycles, so wash them separately at first. Rigid cotton pairs like the Cassie can shrink slightly with heat, so skip the dryer if the fit is right. Stretch versions recover their shape after a rest day between wears, and dryer heat is what wears elastane out fastest. Check the pocket bags and seam edges occasionally, since thinner linings wear through before the denim does. Follow the care label on your specific pair.
Resale data
Pistola straight-leg resale is thinner than premium-tier resale, with prices on Poshmark and Mercari depending on wash, size and condition. The Cassie is the most searched name, so it tends to move fastest secondhand. The RealReal does not consistently list Pistola because the price point sits below its usual curation range.
Where a Pistola straight sits in a multi-pair rotation
If your closet already has the AGOLDE Riley or the Mother Hustler, a cropped Charlie reads as the casual second pair, and the Lexi adds a curved-leg shape you probably do not have yet. If a Pistola straight is your only premium-adjacent straight leg, the full-length Cassie is the better year-round option, since a 27-inch crop reads short under cooler-weather boots.
The verdict
Buy the Cassie if you want a super-high-rise, vintage-feel straight in rigid cotton at a lower price than AGOLDE or Mother. Buy the Charlie if you want an easy cropped high-rise straight with some give. Buy the Lexi if you want the bowed-leg trend in a mid rise. Skip the Bobbie and Lennon if a straight leg is what you want: they are a wide leg and a cropped bootcut. Cross-shop the Pistola Penny wide leg, Pistola barrel, and the petite line to round out the brand picture.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
What are Pistola’s straight leg jeans called?
Pistola’s straight cuts are the Cassie Super High Rise Straight, the Charlie High Rise Classic Straight Ankle and the Lexi Mid Rise Bowed Straight, with cropped and petite versions of some styles. The Bobbie is a wide leg and the Lennon is a cropped bootcut, so neither is a straight.
Do Pistola straight leg jeans run true to size?
It depends on the cut. Several Cassie and Lexi listings note that the style runs large, and Pistola suggests sizing down in the Lexi for a closer fit. Stretch versions of the Charlie are more forgiving. Check the size notes on each listing.
What is the inseam on the Pistola Cassie?
It varies by wash, mostly 30 to 31 inches, with some washes at 28 inches. The Petite Cassie is listed at 28 inches. The Charlie is a cropped 27 inches and the Lexi is listed at 29 inches.
Are Pistola straight leg jeans stretchy?
Several Cassie washes and most Lexi washes are listed as rigid, non-stretch cotton. The Charlie comes in versions with some stretch, including a 99% cotton, 1% spandex wash. Check the fabric line on the specific listing.
Is Pistola comparable to AGOLDE Riley?
The Cassie is the closest Pistola comparison in rise and vintage feel, at a lower full price than the Riley. Compare the listed rise, inseam and fabric, since the two brands cut and grade differently.
How well does Pistola denim wear over time?
Pistola denim wears well for its premium-adjacent price, but how it holds up depends on the fabric of the specific wash. The rigid 100% cotton Cassie and Lexi washes hold their shape and wear in like vintage denim once they break in over a few wears. Lighter stretch and rayon blends feel comfortable immediately but are more prone to pilling at the inner thigh. Pocket bags and seam edges are the weak points, since thinner linings tend to wear through before the denim does.