Reviews

Is Nuuly Worth It? How the Rental Subscription Works

Is Nuuly Worth It? How the Rental Subscription Works

Nuuly lets you rent six pieces of clothing a month for a flat fee, then send them back and pick six more. Whether that is a bargain or an expensive habit depends almost entirely on how you get dressed.

Is Nuuly worth it? For the right person, yes. Nuuly is a Philadelphia-based monthly clothing-rental subscription owned by URBN, the company behind Urban Outfitters, Anthropologie and Free People. At the time of writing, its official page lists “$98 a month” for “any six items you choose,” with no late, shipping or damage fees. It is a large, established service, reported to have averaged roughly 420,000 active subscribers in its last fiscal year. This Nuuly review explains how the rental works, the math on value, what the complaints are, what happened to Nuuly’s resale app and how it compares with buying secondhand or renting elsewhere. For the wider picture on renting, reselling and thrifting, see our Thrift and Resale Fashion hub.

How Nuuly rental works

Nuuly was announced on 21 May 2019 and launched that summer. According to its official how-it-works page at the time of writing:

  • The subscription costs “$98 a month,” with an introductory offer of “$70 for the first month” using the code TRYNUULY.
  • Each month you choose “any six items.”
  • If you love something, you can buy it at a discount.
  • To unlock your next month’s picks, rentals must be “received and processed by our returns team” by your billing date.
  • “No late, shipping or damage fees—it’s all included.”
  • You can “pause or cancel whenever you’d like.”

That return rule is the one to understand. Your next box depends on your previous items being received and processed by the billing date, not simply posted. Send returns back early in the cycle rather than the day before you are billed.

Is Nuuly worth it? The math

The simplest way to judge value is cost per item. At $98 for six items, you are paying a little over $16 per piece per month. If you would otherwise buy several new pieces a month and wear each only a few times, renting can come out ahead, especially for occasion pieces, trend items or seasonal clothes you would not wear for years.

If you mostly wear basics on repeat, the math works against you. Six rented items you return do not build a wardrobe. In that case, buying a few well-made basics or shopping secondhand will deliver more value per dollar.

The subscription works best for people who enjoy variety, dress for a workplace or social calendar that rewards it, and are disciplined about returning on time. It works worst for anyone who forgets about packages, which delays the next month.

Nuuly reviews: weighing the complaints

At the time of writing, Nuuly holds a 1.7 out of 5 on Trustpilot, but from only about 89 reviews. That is a very small sample for a service reported to have about 420,000 average active subscribers, so it is not a representative score. It is still useful for spotting patterns.

The complaints focus on garments arriving worn, pilled or smelly, billing after returns, and friction with support. Worn rentals are an inherent risk of any rental model, since items are shared. Billing complaints connect directly to the “received and processed” rule above, which is why getting returns back early matters. Keep a Portable Clothes Steamer on Amazon at home; a quick steam refreshes rental pieces that arrive creased from shipping.

Top-selling match on Amazon

HiLIFE Steamer for Clothes, Portable Handheld Design, 240ml Big Capacity, 700W, Strong Penetrating Steam, Remo

HiLIFE Steamer for Clothes, Portable Handheld Design, 240ml Big Capacity, 700W, Strong Penetrating Steam, Removes…

  • [Easy to Use] This 700W steamer generates gentle, long-lasting steam and has a 8.5- foot power…
  • [Portable]This garment steamer is portable and lightweight, making it an ideal companion. This…
$24.99(as of November 2026)Check price on Amazon

What happened to Nuuly Thrift

Nuuly once ran a peer-to-peer resale app called Nuuly Thrift, launched in 2021. It was quietly shut down in 2025 and replaced by a Thrift Shop that sells only ex-rental Nuuly inventory. So Nuuly is no longer a place to sell your own clothes. If you want to resell, look at a dedicated platform; our Is Poshmark Legit? Posh Protect, Fees and Scams to Avoid review covers one popular option. The Thrift Shop can still be a way to buy former rental pieces outright.

How Nuuly compares

Option Model Returns / protection Typical risk Best for
Nuuly Monthly rental subscription; six items for $98 No late, shipping or damage fees; pause or cancel anytime Worn or pilled garments; billing tied to return processing Variety without buying
Rent the Runway Clothing rental service Varies; check its current plans Varies Shoppers comparing rental plans
Poshmark Peer-to-peer resale marketplace Posh Protect; 3 days after delivery to open a case Short claim window; fit not covered Buying pieces to keep at secondhand prices

On Nuuly vs Rent the Runway: both are clothing rental services, and we have not verified Rent the Runway’s current plans or pricing, so compare them directly on each company’s site using your own wardrobe habits. Focus on how many items you get, how swaps work and what happens to billing if a return is delayed.

Buying secondhand is the other real alternative. On Poshmark, you keep what you buy, but you only have 3 days after delivery to report a problem. For buying basics new with a long return safety net, see Is Quince Legit? Cashmere, Quality and the 365-Day Returns.

The verdict

Nuuly is worth it if you crave variety, would otherwise buy pieces you wear only a few times, and will send returns back promptly. At $98 for six items a month, with shipping and damage fees included and a pause-anytime policy, it is a fair deal for that shopper. It is not worth it if you live in basics or tend to let packages sit, because billing is tied to returns being processed. Ignore the tiny Trustpilot sample as a score, but take its themes seriously: inspect each rental and return early.

Shop the look on Amazon

Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.

Browse picks on Amazon →

FAQ

How much does Nuuly cost?

At the time of writing, Nuuly lists “$98 a month” for six items, with an introductory “$70 for the first month” using code TRYNUULY.

Can you sell clothes on Nuuly?

No. Nuuly Thrift, its peer-to-peer resale app, shut down in 2025. Its Thrift Shop now sells only ex-rental Nuuly inventory.

Does Nuuly charge late fees?

No. Nuuly says there are no late, shipping or damage fees. Your next month’s items unlock once returns are received and processed.

Is Nuuly a good choice for renting an outfit for one occasion?

Nuuly suits occasion dressing best when you have several events or want variety across a month, because it is a monthly subscription of six items rather than a single-outfit rental. One event-ready dress can sit alongside five other picks in the same box, and you can pause or cancel whenever you like. If you love a piece after the event, Nuuly lets you buy it at a discount instead of returning it.