Guides

How to Thrift: A Beginner’s Guide to Finding Good Clothes

Thrifted finds laid out on a bed, including a rust knit sweater, cream shirts and a beige jacket on hangers

Thrifting rewards a little preparation. Knowing which kind of store you are in, what to check on each piece and how your local sales work turns a random rummage into a reliable way to build a wardrobe.

Learning how to thrift comes down to three things: choosing the right store format for your goal, checking each item carefully before you pay, and caring for your finds once they are home. This beginner guide covers all three, using what named Goodwill organisations and the FTC say where a source exists, and clearly labelled common advice where it does not. When you are ready to put finds together, our Thrifted Outfits hub has outfit ideas built around secondhand pieces.

Quick answer

Go with a short list and a budget. Pick a store format that suits your time: regular thrift stores are sorted by department and size, outlets sell by the pound from bins, and boutiques are curated. Check every size section, read the fibre and care labels, inspect seams, zips and hems in good light, and try things on or measure them. Check the return policy before you buy, then wash everything following the care label.

Check What to look for Why it matters
Fibre label Content and percentages Blends must state percentages under FTC rules
Care label Wash method and temperature Tells you whether you can care for it easily
Seams and stress points Underarms, crotch, hems, pocket corners Splits here are common on worn clothes
Zips and buttons Run the zip fully; count buttons Hardware fixes add time and cost
Stains and wear Check in daylight if you can Store lighting can mask marks
Return policy As-is or exchanges allowed Some outlets sell with no refunds

Step 1: Choose the right kind of thrift store

Thrift formats differ, and the right one depends on your patience and budget.

  • Regular thrift stores. At Goodwill of Central & Southern Indiana’s stores, “Merchandise is organized by departments, and clothing is sorted by size”. This is the easiest place to start.
  • Outlets or bins. These sell mostly by the pound, and prices vary by region. Goodwill Northern New England lists textiles at $2 per pound, and Goodwill Indy lists clothing at just under $2 per pound. Goodwill Indy’s outlet sells as-is with no refunds or exchanges. Read our Goodwill Outlet (The Bins) guide before your first visit.
  • Boutiques. Curated, higher-end Goodwill stores with less digging. See Goodwill Boutique Stores.
  • Vintage and consignment. Higher prices, more editing. Our Consignment Store vs Thrift Store comparison explains the difference.

Step 2: Prepare before you go

  1. Write a short list of what you need, such as “dark jeans” or “wool sweater”.
  2. Set a spending limit for the trip.
  3. Note your key measurements: waist, hips, inseam and chest.
  4. Bring a tape measure and a reusable bag.
  5. Check your local store’s sale days and colour tag schedule. Our guides to the Best Day to Go to Goodwill (and How to Find Your Store’s Schedule) and the How Goodwill Color Tag Sales Work explain how regional schedules work.
  6. Wear easy layers if you plan to try things on over your clothes.

For outlets, Goodwill Northern New England adds two practical tips: “Gloves are a good idea,” and “Stay aware of the bins being switched. You’ll need to step back and wait for employees to move bins into place.”

Step 3: What to look for at thrift stores

Once you are on the floor, these thrift store tips are common advice from experienced shoppers rather than rules from any one source.

  • Check every size section. Sizing varies by brand and era, so a piece labelled two sizes away may still fit. Measurements matter more than the tag.
  • Read the fibre label first. Under FTC rules, blends must state percentages, so a label reading “80% Wool, 20% Cashmere” tells you exactly what you are getting. For tips on natural fibres, see How to Tell Real Silk (and Real Cashmere) When Thrifting.
  • Look for leather disclosures. Under the FTC Leather Guides, material that looks like leather but is not should be disclosed, for example “Not leather” or “Imitation leather”. Those Guides cover purses, luggage, wallets, footwear and similar products. Our How to Tell Real Leather From Leather-Look Materials guide has more checks.
  • Inspect stress points. Look at underarms, the crotch, hems, pocket corners and collar edges for splits or thinning.
  • Test the hardware. Run zips the full length and check buttons and snaps.
  • Look for stains in good light. Hold items near a window if possible.
  • Smell it. Musty or smoky odours can often be washed out, but factor in the effort.

Step 4: Try on or measure

If there is a fitting room, use it. If not, measure a garment you already own that fits well, then compare. Lay jeans flat and measure across the waist, or hold a sweater up against your shoulders. Measurements are just data; they help you find what fits you, nothing more.

Step 5: Decide, pay and check the policy

Before you pay, ask yourself whether you would buy it new at a similar price, and whether you will need to repair it. Check the return policy, because some stores, including Goodwill Indy’s outlet, sell as-is. Small fixes are often worth it: our Thrift Flip Ideas guide covers simple hems, patches and dyeing.

Common beginner mistakes

  • Buying because the price is low rather than because the piece fits your list.
  • Assuming a national sale day or restock day exists. Schedules vary by region.
  • Skipping the care label and ending up with a dry-clean-only piece you will not maintain.
  • Wearing finds before washing them.

Thrift note

Wash everything before it goes into your wardrobe. Our How to Wash and Clean Thrifted Clothes guide follows FTC care-label guidance and EPA advice on bed bugs. Handy kit for thrifting trips includes a Retractable Tape Measure For Sewing on Amazon, a Foldable Reusable Shopping Tote on Amazon and a pair of Work Gloves For Sorting on Amazon for outlet bins.

Top-selling match on Amazon

LHZK Standing Extra Large Utility Tote Bag with Metal Wire Frame and the Sides Rinforced, Extra Large Tote Bag

LHZK Standing Extra Large Utility Tote Bag with Metal Wire Frame and the Sides Rinforced, Extra Large Tote Bag with…

  • 【Stand up Design】Simply stretch the utility tote out, it will stand up and keep upright on its…
  • 【Reinforced Design】Grocery tote bag metal wire frame on the open top so it stays open and the…
$23.74(as of November 2026)Check price on Amazon

Top-selling match on Amazon

Perfect Measuring Tape - Premium Retractable Tailor’s Tape Measure & Crafters Tape – 80″ / 2m - Pocket Sized F

Perfect Measuring Tape – Premium Retractable Tailor’s Tape Measure & Crafters Tape – 80″ / 2m – Pocket Sized Fractional…

  • Easy Read Fractions: Inch side includes easy-to-read printed fractions making quick measurements easy and…
  • Perfect Sewing Measuring Tape: Sewing tape measure, seamstress tape measure, tailor tape, sewing tape, fabric…
  • Better Than A Ruler: Easily portable and compact enough to fit in your pocket. Keep it in your sewing…
$9.99(as of November 2026)Check price on Amazon

Shop the look on Amazon

Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.

Browse picks on Amazon →

FAQ

How do I start thrifting for beginners?

Start at a regular thrift store sorted by size, bring a short list and a budget, and focus on checking labels, seams and fit. Move on to outlets once you are comfortable.

What is the best day to thrift?

There is no single best day. Each Goodwill is run locally, so check your store’s sale days and colour tags.

Should I wash thrifted clothes before wearing them?

Yes, wash or clean them following the care label first. See our washing guide for details, including what the EPA says about bed bugs.

Can I return thrift store items?

It depends on the store. Goodwill Indy’s outlet sells as-is with no refunds or exchanges, so check each store’s policy.