I’ve sent in three ThredUp Clean Out Kits. The payouts varied wildly — from $11 on one kit to $87 on another — and understanding why helped me decide when to use the service and when to sell myself instead.
ThredUp consignment (the Clean Out Kit model) is the selling side of the platform most buyers don’t think about until their closet starts overflowing. The value proposition sounds clean: fill a bag, mail it back, they handle listing and selling, you get paid. The reality is more nuanced. Payouts depend heavily on brand tier, the platform’s discretion on what to accept, and whether you choose cash or store credit. This piece walks through what I actually earned across three kits and the decision framework I now use. For broader platform context, see the Thredup Review main review and our Brand Guides hub on the full resale landscape.
How ThredUp’s Clean Out Kit actually works
The mechanics: you request a Clean Out Kit (free for standard, or paid expedited options exist). It arrives as a pre-labeled bag with prepaid return shipping. You fill it with clothing, accessories, or shoes you want to sell, ship it back using the included label, and ThredUp processes it on arrival at one of their distribution centers (Lancaster, Suwanee, Mechanicsburg).
What ThredUp does with your items: they inspect, grade condition, decide what to list and what to reject, photograph and list the accepted items, and handle any sales. Rejected items are either recycled, donated, or (for a fee) shipped back to you. The default is to not return rejected items unless you explicitly opt for the paid Return Assurance option.
Payout timing: you see “Pending” earnings immediately after they process your kit, but you don’t get paid until an item actually sells. Unsold items sit in inventory for a window (typically 60-90 days) before being removed. If an item doesn’t sell in that window, you earn nothing on it.
The payout structure — and why it’s low
ThredUp’s payout is calculated as a percentage of the listed price, tiered by what ThredUp lists the item at. The percentages escalate with listing price:
Items listed under $5: you earn roughly 5% of the listed price (often rounded to pennies on the dollar).
Items listed $5-$19.99: roughly 15-20% payout.
Items listed $20-$49.99: roughly 30-40% payout.
Items listed $50-$99.99: roughly 50-60% payout.
Items listed $100-$199.99: roughly 60-70% payout.
Items listed $200+: up to 80% payout.
These tiers are approximate and have changed over time — ThredUp publishes their current payout percentages on their site. The key structural point: low-priced items pay almost nothing to the seller. A $12 blouse that ThredUp lists earns the seller maybe $2. Most clothing in a normal person’s closet falls into the $10-$30 listing range, which means payouts of $3-$10 per item at best.
My three kits, actual numbers
Kit one. I sent in 28 items — a mix of J.Crew, Banana Republic, Gap, Old Navy, some unbranded pieces. ThredUp accepted 19 items for listing and rejected 9. Over 90 days, 14 of the listed items sold. My total payout was $11.32 in cash, or $13.07 in store credit (credit pays ~15% more).
Breakdown: the rejected items were mostly the unbranded pieces and a couple of items with visible wear. Accepted items listed at an average of $8.50 each. At roughly 15% payout on those price points, my net per sold item was around $1. The kit took me maybe 20 minutes to pack. Hourly rate for the selling effort: approximately $3.40.
Kit two. I sent in 15 items, but this time curated for higher-value brands — a Madewell jacket, three Anthropologie dresses, a J.Crew silk blouse, some nicer items. ThredUp accepted 11 and rejected 4. Eight of the accepted items sold over 90 days. My payout: $43.18 cash, $49.66 credit.
Breakdown: listing prices averaged closer to $25, pushing me into the 30-40% payout tier. The Madewell jacket alone listed at $68 and sold for full list, netting me around $27. Hourly rate on this kit: significantly better, probably $15-$20 effective.
Kit three. I made it deliberate — only higher-end pieces: a cashmere sweater, a Theory blazer, two pairs of designer denim, a silk Equipment shirt. Ten items total. ThredUp accepted 9 and rejected 1. Seven sold within 90 days. Total payout: $87.40 cash, $100.51 credit.
Breakdown: listing prices averaged $45+, lifting me into better payout tiers. The Theory blazer alone paid out $32. This kit confirmed what I’d started to suspect: ThredUp consignment works for higher-end items, not for closet-clearing of mid-range pieces.
Cash vs. credit: the 15% decision
ThredUp pays out in either cash (direct deposit or PayPal) or in store credit. Store credit runs approximately 15% higher than cash — meaning a $10 cash payout would be roughly $11.50 in credit.
Whether to take cash or credit depends on your ThredUp usage. If you shop ThredUp regularly, credit is effectively free money — take it. If you don’t shop ThredUp often, cash is better even at a lower payout, because credit that sits unused is worth nothing.
My pattern: I take credit when my cash-equivalent payout is $20+, because I know I’ll use it within a year. I take cash when the payout is small, because tying up small credits across platforms fragments my finances.
When thredup consignment is actually worth it
Three conditions where ThredUp consignment makes sense:
First, you have higher-end items you don’t want to list yourself. A cashmere sweater, a Theory blazer, designer denim — these fall into payout tiers where ThredUp’s cut is tolerable. The convenience of not listing them yourself may genuinely be worth the lower net versus Poshmark.
Second, you have enough volume to make the selling-yourself option burdensome. If you’re clearing out 50 items, listing each one on Poshmark takes significant time. Sending them in a Clean Out Kit and accepting the lower payout may save enough time to be a reasonable trade.
Third, you specifically want store credit. If you shop ThredUp anyway, the credit payout compounds your buying power and the lower nominal value matters less.
When to skip ThredUp consignment
Two conditions where selling yourself beats ThredUp consignment significantly:
You have individual high-value pieces (designer, vintage, authentic luxury). A genuine Chanel jacket going through ThredUp consignment will pay out significantly less than the same jacket listed on Poshmark, Mercari, or TheRealReal. For high-value items, the time investment of individual listing pays back multiples of the ThredUp payout.
You have commodity clothing you’re willing to discount aggressively to move. ThredUp will reject many mid-to-low tier brand items or pay pennies on them. Listing them yourself at $5-$10 on Poshmark or Mercari and accepting lower offers can net you more than the fraction of a dollar ThredUp pays per rejected or low-tier item.
What ThredUp rejects and why
ThredUp publishes guidelines on what they accept, and they reject items for consistent reasons:
Condition: visible stains, significant pilling, broken zippers, missing buttons, strong odors. These get rejected even on higher-tier brands.
Brand tier: they maintain a list of accepted brands and will reject many ultra-low-tier fast fashion pieces (Shein, H&M sometimes, anything particularly cheap). Acceptance criteria change and aren’t fully transparent.
Season: off-season items may be rejected to keep inventory current. Sending a wool coat in April might get it rejected even if it’s in good condition.
Style: outdated fashion that ThredUp predicts won’t sell. This is subjective and sometimes frustrating.
What happens to rejected items is important. Default behavior: they’re recycled, donated to partner organizations, or disposed of. They’re not returned unless you paid for Return Assurance at kit request. Most sellers don’t realize this — they assume rejected items come back. They don’t. Once your kit ships, those items are gone from your closet regardless of ThredUp’s decision on each piece.
Return Assurance: the hidden cost
Return Assurance is a paid upgrade that guarantees ThredUp will ship rejected items back to you instead of disposing of them. It costs extra at kit selection. For high-value items that might be rejected, Return Assurance is reasonable. For a mixed-quality closet purge, it often costs more than the items are worth.
My own approach after kit one: I stopped including anything I actually wanted to keep if it got rejected. I only send items I’m genuinely willing to part with no matter what ThredUp decides.
For storing the items you’re keeping rather than sending in, a set of Vacuum Storage Bags Space Saver on Amazon can compress out-of-season pieces significantly — more useful than paying Return Assurance on marginal items.
Tax implications for significant sellers
ThredUp issues 1099-K forms to sellers who exceed IRS reporting thresholds in a calendar year. The threshold has shifted with recent legislation. Any payouts you receive are taxable income regardless of whether you receive a 1099-K.
For casual sellers processing one or two kits per year with modest payouts, this is usually minor. For volume sellers, keeping records of payouts from each kit and reconciling against 1099-K forms at tax time matters.
The verdict
Thredup consignment is a convenience product, not a maximizing product. The payouts are lower than selling yourself on peer-to-peer platforms — sometimes significantly lower. The convenience is real: you fill a bag, mail it, and eventually money appears. For people who value that convenience and have the right inventory (higher-end items that fit ThredUp’s brand acceptance), it’s a reasonable trade.
For anyone trying to maximize return on a closet purge, selling yourself beats ThredUp’s payout model. The Clean Out Kit is not a money-making tool — it’s a time-saving tool with modest monetary compensation. Understand which it is before you commit your inventory, and don’t expect more than it delivers.
My actual rule now: kit three’s numbers convinced me to only send Clean Out Kits that are curated toward higher-end pieces. Kit one’s numbers convinced me to never send mid-range closet clearings again. For those, Apps Like Poshmark outperforms the ThredUp consignment model by multiples.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
How much does ThredUp pay out per item?
Payouts scale with listing price — from roughly 5% on sub-$5 items up to 80% on items $200+. Most mid-range clothing pays 15-40% of the ThredUp listing price.
Does ThredUp return rejected items?
Only if you paid for Return Assurance at kit request. Default behavior is that rejected items are recycled, donated, or disposed of — not returned.
Is it better to take cash or credit from ThredUp?
Credit pays approximately 15% more than cash. Take credit if you shop ThredUp regularly. Take cash if you don’t, because unused credit is worth nothing.
Does ThredUp accept all brands?
No. They maintain an internal list of accepted brands and reject many low-tier fast fashion labels. Higher-end and mid-range branded items have much better acceptance rates.
How long does ThredUp consignment take to pay out?
Items must actually sell before you get paid. Typical sell-through timeline is 30-90 days. Items that don’t sell within ThredUp’s window earn you nothing.
