thredUP does the work and keeps most of the money on cheap items. Poshmark makes you do the work and lets you keep most of the money. Your time decides which deal is better.
thredUP vs Poshmark is not really a fee comparison. It is a choice between two different ways of selling. thredUP is consignment: you mail a bag, and it inspects, photographs, prices and lists what it accepts. Poshmark is peer-to-peer: you photograph, price, list, answer buyers and ship each item yourself. The payouts reflect that. Below, the fees, payout bands, timelines and effort side by side, all as of October 2026. Both platforms change terms, so check thredUP’s fee help page and Poshmark’s fee page before you commit a bag of clothes. Other ways to sell secondhand are covered on our Thrift and Resale Fashion hub.
thredUP vs Poshmark: the quick answer
Use thredUP if you have a large bag of everyday clothes, little time, and you mainly want the closet cleared. Use Poshmark if you have branded or higher-value pieces and are willing to spend time listing and shipping to keep most of the sale price. Many people do both: higher-value items on Poshmark, the rest in a thredUP Clean Out bag.
How thredUP and Poshmark compare
| Dimension | thredUP | Poshmark |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Consignment: thredUP inspects, prices and lists | Peer-to-peer: you list, price and ship |
| Fees | Clean Out service fee: $14.99 Standard or $34.99 Premium, taken only after items sell | $2.95 under $15; 20% at $15 and up |
| Your share | Approx. 3–15% on items selling at $5–19.99, rising to about 80% at $200+ | 80% on sales of $15 and up |
| Shipping | Free label to send your bag in | Buyer pays $6.49 flat per order, up to 5 lb |
| Time to sale | Processing about 21–28 days Standard, about 14 days Premium | Depends on your listings and price |
| Effort | Pack one bag | Photograph, list, answer offers, ship each sale |
| Best for | Bulk everyday clothing, low effort | Branded pieces worth $15+, maximum payout |
thredUP’s payout bands come from a secondary source citing thredUP’s own guide; use thredUP’s payout estimator for the current figures on a specific brand.
What thredUP costs and pays
thredUP charges a Clean Out Kit service fee of $14.99 for Standard or $34.99 for Premium. It is deducted from your earnings only after items sell, and if your earnings come in below the fee, you are not charged the difference. Shipping labels are free. Optional add-ons include a 30-lb Clean Out bag for $2.99 (Premium bags are free), an Uber pickup for $4.99 covering up to five Clean Outs, and $5.99 per item plus return shipping to reclaim something that did not sell. thredUP has sometimes waived the Standard fee as a promotion, so check the Clean Out page before ordering a kit.
Payouts scale with the final selling price. Approximate bands: 3–15% for items selling at $5 to $19.99, 15–30% at $20 to $49.99, 30–60% at $50 to $99.99, 60–80% at $100 to $199.99, and up to about 80% at $200 and above. In other words, a top that sells for $12 earns you roughly $0.36 to $1.80, while a high-value designer piece can earn close to what Poshmark would pay. Earnings arrive only after an item sells and the buyer’s return window passes, as thredUP credit that can be converted to cash or partner shopping credit.
Not everything is accepted. Acceptance runs about 60–80% of Standard items and 80–90% of Premium items. Common rejection reasons include styles older than about five years, visible wear, brands thredUP does not carry, oversupplied categories and items that would not sell for the $5 minimum. Unaccepted Standard items are reused or recycled, not mailed back; Premium items are returned by default. For the details, see Selling Clothes on ThredUp and ThredUp Fees Explained.
What Poshmark costs and pays
Poshmark charges $2.95 on sales under $15 and 20% on sales of $15 and up, so on most clothing you keep 80%. The buyer pays a flat $6.49 shipping label for parcels up to 5 lb. After delivery, buyers have 3 days to open a case; otherwise the money is released to you, and direct deposit is free. Our Poshmark Fees Explained page has worked examples at different price points.
The cost Poshmark does not list is your time: photographing, writing listings, responding to offers, sharing and packing each order. For items worth $25 or more, that time is usually well rewarded. For a $6 tank top, it often is not. If you go the Poshmark route, a Fabric Shaver For Clothes on Amazon is a cheap way to clean up pilled knits so they photograph better.
Top-selling match on Amazon
- 【Portable Fabric Shaver】– Special designed for removing fuzz, pills, and lint from sweaters…
- 【Innovative Blades】 — Upgraded 6 Leaf Blades, razor-sharp, double cleaning efficiency…
Choose thredUP if, choose Poshmark if
Choose thredUP if you have more clothes than time, most items are everyday mall or fast-fashion brands, you would rather have the closet cleared than maximize the payout, and you accept that some items will be rejected and recycled.
Choose Poshmark if your pieces are recognizable brands worth $15 or more, you are willing to put in the listing work, you want to set your own prices, and you want to keep 80% of each sale.
Weighing a third option? Our Mercari vs Poshmark comparison covers a lower-fee self-listing alternative.
The verdict
For money, Poshmark wins comfortably on almost everything under $100. Keeping 80% of a sale beats a 3–30% share by a wide margin. thredUP only closes the gap on high-value items, where its payout rises toward about 80%, and those are exactly the items worth listing yourself anyway. thredUP’s real product is convenience: one bag, no photos, no buyers. Treat it as a paid closet clean-out rather than a way to earn. The smartest split is to sell anything branded or worth $25 or more on Poshmark, then send the leftover everyday pieces to thredUP so they leave the house with no further effort.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
Does thredUP or Poshmark pay more?
Poshmark pays more on most items. Sellers keep 80% of sales of $15 and up. thredUP pays an approximate 3–15% share on items selling under $20, rising to about 80% at $200 and above.
Does thredUP charge a fee to sell?
Yes. The Clean Out service fee is $14.99 for Standard or $34.99 for Premium, deducted only after items sell. Promotions sometimes waive the Standard fee.
What happens to clothes thredUP rejects?
Unaccepted Standard items are reused or recycled and not returned. Premium Clean Outs return unaccepted items by default.
How long does thredUP take to process a bag?
About 21–28 days for Standard and about 14 days for Premium, per a secondary source citing thredUP’s selling guide.
What clothes does thredUP accept from a Clean Out bag?
thredUP accepts about 60 to 80% of Standard Clean Out items and about 80 to 90% of Premium items. Common rejection reasons include styles older than about five years, visible wear, brands thredUP does not carry, oversupplied categories and items that would not sell for the $5 minimum. Unaccepted Standard items are reused or recycled rather than mailed back, while Premium items are returned by default, so Premium suits bags with pieces worth getting back.
When and how does thredUP pay sellers?
thredUP pays sellers only after an item sells and the buyer’s return window passes. Earnings arrive as thredUP credit, which can be converted to cash or to partner shopping credit. The Clean Out service fee of $14.99 for Standard or $34.99 for Premium is deducted from those earnings, and sellers are not charged the difference if earnings come in below the fee. Processing a bag takes about 21 to 28 days for Standard or about 14 days for Premium.