Macy’s carries a multi-brand shoes assortment across women’s, men’s, and kids’, covering casual, dressy, athletic, boots, sandals, and heels. Sizes typically run 5 to 12 women’s and 7 to 14 men’s, with extended sizes and widths on select brands.
We tracked Macy’s shoes for Tumbleweed Thrift readers because the category is one of the strongest reasons to shop Macy’s over a single-brand store, but the assortment varies wildly by location and shoppers often arrive expecting brand depth that the local store does not actually carry. Macy’s runs a mid-tier brand mix with strong representation across the casual, dressy, athletic, and boots subcategories, and the Star Rewards stacking adds genuine value to the per-purchase math. This review walks through the brand mix by subcategory, the pricing tiers, the sizing range, and how Macy’s shoes stacks up against Nordstrom Rack and DSW in the same price band. For broader brand context, see the Off Price Outlet Retailers hub.
Macy’s shoes assortment at a glance
The Macy’s shoe department typically carries 30 to 50 brands at any given time, with roughly 5,000 to 10,000 SKUs in stock at the larger locations. Sizes 5 through 12 women’s are standard, with select brands extending to 4 and 13. Men’s sizing runs 7 to 14 standard with select brands extending to 15. Wide widths are available on a smaller subset of brands including Naturalizer, Clarks, and several of the boot specialists. Kids’ shoes run a smaller assortment with fewer brands, typically the major kids-shoe specialists plus the kids’ lines from athletic brands.
The multi-brand strength is the editorial advantage over single-brand stores. You can shop a Sam Edelman alongside a Steve Madden alongside a Coach in one trip, with Star Rewards points stacking across the entire purchase. The trade-off is that the assortment depth per brand is shallower than the brand’s own store would carry. If you want the full Steve Madden line, the brand’s own store has more SKUs.
Best Macy’s brands for women’s casual
The women’s casual category is one of Macy’s strongest. Clarks runs the broadest comfort-tier assortment with classic styles plus the Cloudsteppers line. Steve Madden covers the trendier casual mid-tier with sneakers, slides, and casual loafers. Sam Edelman runs slightly upmarket with classic loafers, ballet flats, and casual ankle boots. Naturalizer is the comfort-with-style anchor with broader sizing and width availability. Jessica Simpson and Anne Klein cover the entry-tier casual heels and flats. Vince Camuto fills the slightly-elevated casual mid-tier. INC International Concepts is Macy’s own brand at the entry-mid tier with frequent banner pricing.
For a broader sandal or summer-casual stock-up, the Steve Madden and Sam Edelman selection is generally the strongest. Cross-link Macy’s Dresses for the dresses-and-shoes outfit-coordination context.
Best Macy’s brands for women’s dressy and heels
The dressy and heels category leans heavily on the same mid-tier brands plus a few specialists. Sam Edelman runs the broadest dressy heels assortment with stiletto, block heel, and pumps in classic colors. Steve Madden covers the trendier party heels and platforms. Vince Camuto fills the mid-tier dressy assortment with broader color options. Marc Fisher covers the working-professional dressy mid-tier. Coach provides the premium-tier dressy heels at scale, with classic pumps and platforms in leather.
Anne Klein covers the entry-mid dressy tier with frequent banner pricing. For wedding-guest or formal occasion shopping, the Sam Edelman and Vince Camuto lines are the strongest cross-pairs with the Macy’s Dresses formal categories. Pricing in this subcategory typically runs $80 to $250 with banner sales pulling down to $40 to $150.
Best Macy’s brands for men’s
The men’s shoe assortment is strongest in the dressy and casual-dressy subcategories. Cole Haan runs the broadest men’s dressy and dress-casual assortment with leather oxfords, loafers, and the ZeroGrand casual line. Clarks covers the casual-comfort tier with desert boots and casual loafers. Johnston and Murphy provides the premium-tier dressy options with leather oxfords and monk straps. Florsheim covers the value-tier dressy assortment with classic styling. Polo Ralph Lauren runs the preppy-classic mid-tier with leather lace-ups and casual boat shoes. Nautica covers the casual men’s tier including boat shoes and casual loafers. Calvin Klein fills the modern-classic mid-tier with leather oxfords and dress sneakers.
The men’s shoe pricing typically runs $60 to $200 for most subcategories, with Cole Haan hitting $150 to $300 at the premium tier. Cross-link Macys Mens Pants for the men’s-outfit-coordination context.
Best Macy’s brands for athletic and sneakers
The athletic assortment is solid but not the deepest among multi-brand stores. Nike, Adidas, Skechers, Puma, and New Balance all carry at most Macy’s locations, with the SKU count typically running 50 to 200 sneaker styles depending on store size. The athletic specialty stores like Foot Locker carry a broader sneaker assortment, but Macy’s offers the stack-with-Star-Rewards math that specialty athletic stores do not.
For the Nike or Adidas shopper specifically, Macy’s carries the classic-rotation styles consistently but does not carry the limited-release or exclusive-collab inventory that the brand’s own store and the athletic specialty stores get. If you are buying running shoes or training shoes for general fitness use, Macy’s covers the need at competitive pricing during banner sales.
Best Macy’s brands for boots and outdoor
The boots and outdoor category runs a smaller selection of specialist brands. Sorel covers the cold-weather boot assortment with insulated and waterproof options. Timberland runs the casual outdoor and work-boot crossover. UGG carries a smaller selection at most Macy’s locations, with seasonal availability shifting in fall and winter. Bearpaw covers the value-tier UGG-alternative with shearling-lined options. Frye carries a limited assortment at the premium leather-boot tier.
The outdoor assortment depth is shallower than at REI or Bass Pro Shops, but the casual-fashion-boot crossover is well-represented. For a winter-boot stock-up, the Sorel and Timberland selection is generally where the value sits.
Macy’s shoes pricing tiers
The pricing breaks roughly into three tiers. Entry tier runs $30 to $80 and covers Naturalizer, Skechers, Jessica Simpson, and frequent INC International Concepts banner pricing. Mid tier runs $80 to $200 and covers Steve Madden, Sam Edelman, Vince Camuto, Marc Fisher, and Cole Haan casual lines. Premium tier runs $200 to $500 and covers Cole Haan dressy, Coach, Frye, and the higher-tier UGG and Sorel options.
Banner sales typically pull pricing down 30 to 50 percent across the entire shoe department during major sale events. The deepest cuts come during Black Friday, Cyber Monday, Friends and Family events, and end-of-season clearance. Cross-link Macy’s Black Friday for the sale-window deep-dive and Macy’s Credit Card Login for the Cardholder Bonus stacking math.
Macy’s shoes vs Nordstrom Rack vs DSW
The three multi-brand shoe shopping options serve overlapping but distinct needs. Macy’s is the right choice for brand variety plus multi-category in one trip plus Star Rewards stacking across apparel and shoes. Nordstrom Rack is the right choice for deeper designer discounts on shoes specifically, with the Rack carrying premium-tier brands like Cole Haan, Stuart Weitzman, and Tory Burch at deeper discounts than Macy’s. The Rack’s curation skews more premium and fashion-forward, with frequent rotating clearance. Cross-link Nordstrom Rack Designer Shoes for the deeper Rack-shoes context.
DSW is the right choice for shoes-specifically with the broadest single-store assortment. DSW carries 200 to 400 brands at typical store size, with DSW Rewards as the loyalty program. The trade-off versus Macy’s is that DSW does not let you stack with apparel or home purchases, so the per-trip value is lower if you are shopping multiple categories. For broader off-price-shoes context, browse Designer Womens Shoes on Amazon or Mens Leather Shoes on Amazon as alternative paths.
Macy’s shoes Black Friday and sale events
Major sale events pull shoe pricing down across all brand tiers. Black Friday and Cyber Monday cover the broadest banner with 40 to 60 percent off premium-brand shoes typical. Friends and Family events run roughly twice a year and stack a 25 to 30 percent discount across most categories. End-of-season clearance in late January and late July rotates the seasonal styles into deep discount. The Star Rewards Cardholder Bonus layered with these banners pushes the effective discount higher.
For sale-window planning, the deepest discounts on premium-tier shoes typically come during the Black Friday and Cyber Monday window, with end-of-season clearance covering the deepest cuts on out-of-season styles. Cross-link Macy’s Black Friday for the broader sale-stacking context.
The verdict
Macy’s shoes are the right answer for mid-tier brand variety plus multi-category shopping in one trip plus Star Rewards stacking. Skip for budget-tier exclusives where DSW wins on assortment breadth, or for premium-tier-only shopping where Nordstrom Rack wins on discount depth. The brand mix at Macy’s covers the working-professional, casual-Friday, party-heel, and basic-sneaker needs at competitive pricing during banner sales. The Cardholder Bonus stacking is the genuine cost advantage over the off-price competitors. For the deepest-discount window, plan around Black Friday and Friends and Family events. For online browsing during off-hours, see Womens Dress Shoes on Amazon or browse Macy’s Locations for the in-batch store-finder context. The Macy’s shoes department is one of the strongest reasons to shop Macy’s beyond the apparel categories.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
What sizes does Macy’s carry in women’s shoes?
Standard sizing runs 5 to 12, with select brands extending to 4 and 13. Wide widths are available on a smaller subset of brands including Naturalizer and Clarks. Use macys.com filter options to narrow by size and width.
What’s the best brand at Macy’s for comfort women’s shoes?
Clarks runs the broadest comfort-tier assortment, with the Cloudsteppers line as the cushioned-casual specialty. Naturalizer is the second-strongest comfort brand with broader sizing and width options.
How does Macy’s shoes pricing compare to Nordstrom Rack?
Nordstrom Rack runs deeper discounts on premium-tier brands like Cole Haan and Stuart Weitzman, with rotating clearance. Macy’s runs more consistent pricing with banner sale events, plus Star Rewards stacking across apparel and shoes that the Rack does not offer.
Does Macy’s carry men’s wide-width shoes?
Yes, on a subset of brands. Filter on macys.com for wide-width availability. Cole Haan, Florsheim, and Johnston and Murphy all carry wide options on select styles.
When are Macy’s shoes on sale the most?
The deepest discounts come during Black Friday, Cyber Monday, Friends and Family events (twice a year), and end-of-season clearance in late January and late July. Cardholder Bonus stacking layers on top of these banners.
