There are dozens of second hand apps, but only about six earn permanent space on a phone for most fashion buyers and sellers. The rest are niche, redundant or poorly built. Here’s what separates the categories.
The second hand apps category has exploded, with new entrants launching regularly and existing players adding features constantly. For buyers and sellers trying to figure out which apps deserve permanent space on their phone, the marketing isn’t helpful — every app claims to be “the sustainable alternative” or “the fashion community’s favorite.” What actually matters is how each app performs for the kind of buying and selling you want to do. This piece walks through the six second hand apps worth keeping, what each does best, and why the others don’t earn the space. For related platform comparisons, see Thrift Apps and Apps Like Poshmark. Broader resale context lives in our Brand Guides hub.
The core six
Roughly in order of how often a typical fashion shopper will use them:
Poshmark — the everyday app. The social discovery and negotiation flow work for finding specific items and for selling mid-range branded clothing. 20% commission on items $15+ is the main drawback.
ThredUp — for targeted brand hunts. The strongest search filters in the category make specific brand hunts efficient. Consistent condition grading means fewer surprises, and there’s no seller interaction, which suits certain types of shopping.
Vinted — for lower prices. No seller fees (zero commission; buyers pay a fee at checkout) help keep list prices lower. US inventory is still thinner than Poshmark or ThredUp but growing steadily.
Mercari — for everything beyond fashion. Broader inventory (not fashion-only), lower seller fees than Poshmark, useful for mens clothing and commodity items.
Depop — occasional use. Specific use case: finding trend-driven vintage styled well. Not the app for business casual or basics.
eBay — for specific hunts. Unmatched for vintage denim, vintage menswear, and authenticated designer. Not fashion-optimized but fashion-capable.
What each one does best
Poshmark has the most fashion-focused buyer community in the US. Mid-range brands like J.Crew are exactly what its buyers search for. The social features (bundling, sharing, offers) create discovery paths that algorithmic platforms can’t replicate. The 20% fee is annoying but buyers are willing to pay Poshmark prices, so sellers can absorb the fee into listing prices.
ThredUp has the best search filters, period. Brand + size + condition + color + price as simultaneous constraints. When you know exactly what you want, ThredUp finds it fast. No other second hand app has search this precise.
Vinted’s fee structure is genuinely better for sellers. Zero commission means list prices stay closer to what sellers want to net. For buyers, that often means lower prices than comparable Poshmark listings. Full review at Vinted Review and Vinted App Reviews.
Mercari fills the commodity gap. Items Poshmark sellers don’t emphasize — mens clothing, housewares, general resale — are abundant here. Lower fees help make Mercari profitable for lower-margin items that wouldn’t work on Poshmark.
Depop succeeds in a narrow niche. Trend-forward young fashion, vintage styled as current, Y2K aesthetics. Its buyers skew young, but it’s useful for anyone who wants something specifically from that aesthetic space.
eBay’s depth beats newer platforms for specific categories. Vintage items, niche collectibles, and authenticated luxury all have deeper inventory on eBay than on any fashion-specific second hand app.
What doesn’t earn a spot
Three categories of deletions:
Niche apps for specific audiences. Curtsy (college-focused), Kidizen (children’s), GOAT (sneaker resale). Good apps for their intended users, but not general fashion tools. For the details on fees and payouts, see our Curtsy app guide.
Apps that failed to differentiate. Several newer second hand apps launched with nominally different features but couldn’t overcome Poshmark’s network effects. In practice they offer the same types of inventory you’d see on Poshmark, with fewer listings.
Apps with poor execution. Buggy interfaces, slow load times, unclear policies. Life’s too short for a second hand app that won’t load product photos reliably.
By-use-case recommendations
For buyers hunting specific branded items, use ThredUp first for search efficiency, then Poshmark for broader inventory if ThredUp doesn’t have it.
For buyers who want the lowest prices on available inventory, use Vinted first, then Poshmark if the item isn’t on Vinted.
For buyers looking for vintage or specific collectors’ items, use eBay first, then Etsy vintage shops for curated options.
For buyers interested in trend-driven young fashion, use Depop first, Instagram curated vintage shops second.
For sellers clearing out a closet with minimum effort, use ThredUp’s Clean Out Kit (lowest payout but highest convenience) or Poshmark (higher effort, higher return).
For sellers optimizing return, use Vinted for keeping 100% of listing price, or Poshmark for fastest sell-through at the cost of 20% commission.
For sellers cross-listing seriously, install Poshmark, Vinted, Mercari, and eBay. Use cross-listing tools for anything above 15 items/month volume.
The fee math that matters
Across all second hand apps, the fee structure determines profitability. Quick reference:
Poshmark: 20% above $15, $2.95 flat below. Seller pays. Buyer pays flat shipping.
Mercari: 10% seller fee on the item price and any buyer-paid shipping, with no separate payment processing fee since January 2025. Buyers pay a 3.6% Buyer Protection fee. Seller covers shipping or passes it to the buyer.
Vinted: 0% seller commission. Buyer pays a Vinted fee at checkout, usually 5% + $0.70.
Depop: no selling fee for US sellers, but 3.3% + $0.45 payment processing per transaction. Buyers pay a marketplace fee of up to 5% + $1. Depop has been owned by eBay since July 2026.
eBay: 13.6% final value fee for most clothing, shoes and accessories, calculated on the total sale amount, plus a $0.30–$0.40 per-order fee.
ThredUp: payouts tiered by final selling price (roughly 3% on the cheapest items up to 80% at $200+), and a Clean Out service fee of $14.99 (Standard) or $34.99 (Premium) is deducted from earnings.
For sellers, the effective take-home on a $40 sale (before shipping) varies significantly: Poshmark nets $32, Mercari nets $36, Vinted nets $40, Depop nets about $38 after processing, and eBay nets about $34. Over 100 sales, these differences compound.
Buyer protection comparison
All major second hand apps offer some form of buyer protection, but the specific terms matter:
ThredUp: 14-day return window with a $3.99 restocking fee per item. Some items marked final sale. Returns process through the same distribution center the item shipped from.
Poshmark: 3-day window after delivery to open a case with photo evidence. Poshmark arbitrates, and if no case is opened, payment releases to the seller automatically.
Mercari: 3-day rating window. If you don’t rate the transaction within 3 days of delivery, auto-releases funds. Buyer-friendly if paying attention, risky if forgotten.
Vinted: 2-day window to flag issues after Vinted notifies you the item should have been delivered. Buyer confirms receipt is acceptable before funds release to seller. Cleanest flow of the peer-to-peer options.
Depop: dispute process similar to Poshmark — file with evidence, platform arbitrates.
eBay: Money Back Guarantee covers items not as described, not received, or significantly damaged, with up to 30 days after delivery to report. Most mature dispute system in resale.
App performance and UX
Raw app quality varies across second hand apps:
ThredUp is the most polished — feels like proper e-commerce rather than marketplace. Fast, consistent, few bugs.
Vinted is clean and minimal. European design sensibility shows. Occasional bugs but rare crashes.
Mercari is functional and reliable. Not aesthetically remarkable but does what it needs to do.
Poshmark is visually busy with many features. Handles its complexity reasonably well but can feel overwhelming. Occasional slow loads.
Depop has a strong visual identity but the interface can feel cluttered. Youth-focused design choices that may or may not appeal.
eBay’s mobile app is functional but legacy-feeling. Works reliably but isn’t designed for fashion-specific browsing.
Privacy and data considerations
Second hand apps collect user data like any app. Privacy policies vary — review them for each app if you care about the details. Notable points:
Payment information is handled by the platform’s payment processor in most cases, not stored directly by the app. Credit card data is tokenized.
Shipping addresses are shared with sellers (for peer-to-peer apps) or with the platform’s fulfillment (for consignment apps like ThredUp).
Messaging content within peer-to-peer apps is platform-accessible for dispute resolution. Assume platform staff can read messages when necessary.
Listing data (photos, descriptions, prices) is public. Anyone can see your items for sale and your purchase history to some extent on peer-to-peer platforms.
Managing multiple second hand apps in practice
Running 4-6 second hand apps requires some organization. What works:
Pinned notification settings. Allow transactional notifications (messages, sales, shipping updates) across all apps and disable promotional notifications. This keeps alerts relevant without drowning in marketing.
Saved searches. Every app with saved search functionality (most of them) should get a handful of active searches for specific items you’re hunting. Email or in-app alerts arrive when matches appear.
Separate inbox for resale activity. Route resale-related email notifications to a dedicated folder so they don’t clutter your main inbox.
Cross-listing tools for serious selling. For casual selling (a few items per month), manual management is fine. For active reselling, a cross-listing tool pays for itself quickly.
For the packaging accumulation from multiple apps on the buying side, a collapsible Fabric Storage Cubes Collapsible Pack on Amazon setup keeps unprocessed arrivals organized until you have time to integrate them into your actual wardrobe.
Related reading: Second Hand Thrift Store
Related reading: Thrift Store Apps
The verdict
The best second hand apps aren’t the newest or the trendiest — they’re the ones that reliably serve specific needs. For the average user, three apps installed covers almost every use case: ThredUp for efficient brand searches, Poshmark for broad fashion discovery and social commerce, and Vinted for lower-priced alternatives.
Add Mercari for commodity items or mens focus. Add eBay for vintage and specialty hunts. Skip Depop unless your aesthetic specifically matches its user base. Skip newer entrants until they’ve proven differentiated value — most won’t, and the deletion cost is minimal.
The second hand apps ecosystem isn’t one app to replace retail shopping. It’s a toolkit of specialized options. Use each one for what it does best, rotate through them as your needs shift, and resale becomes a genuinely effective complement (or replacement) for new-retail shopping. Used that way, building a mostly secondhand wardrobe is realistic.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
Browse picks on Amazon →FAQ
What’s the best second hand app?
Depends on use case. ThredUp for search efficiency. Poshmark for broad US fashion. Vinted for lowest prices. Mercari for commodity items. eBay for vintage. No single app wins across all categories — most serious users install 3-5.
Are second hand apps safe for buying clothes?
Yes on major platforms with platform-processed payment and buyer protection. Risks are at the user level (misrepresented items) rather than platform level. Always pay through the app’s payment system to trigger protection.
What’s the cheapest second hand app for sellers?
Vinted charges sellers no commission. Depop charges US sellers no selling fee, just 3.3% + $0.45 processing. Mercari takes 10%. Poshmark’s 20% is highest. For sellers optimizing take-home, Vinted wins, with the trade-off of slower sales velocity in the US.
Do second hand apps actually save money compared to retail?
Yes for mid-range and higher brands. A J.Crew cardigan that retails at $89 typically lists for $20-$35 on resale apps in good condition. Low-tier fast fashion sometimes costs more used than new on clearance.
How do I spot scams on second hand apps?
Check seller ratings and transaction history. Read item descriptions carefully and ask questions if anything is unclear. Never pay outside the platform’s payment system. Prices dramatically below market for high-value items are often too-good-to-be-true warning signs.