Guides

Men’s Resale Shop: The Best Platforms for Guys

Man in a tan overshirt holding a grey blazer from a rack of secondhand men's jackets

Men’s resale has finally grown past the dusty Goodwill rack stereotype. The platforms that specialize in secondhand menswear now carry inventory that rivals most retail stores.

The quality of the men’s resale market has improved dramatically in recent years. What used to be a scattered landscape of eBay listings and picked-over thrift stores is now a legitimate retail channel with dedicated platforms, curated inventory, and real savings. Heritage outerwear from brands like Filson, Goodyear-welted shoes from makers like Allen Edmonds, and mid-range shirting from J.Crew and Brooks Brothers all turn up secondhand at a fraction of retail, often in excellent condition. Here are the platforms worth your time, judged on selection, pricing, buyer protection and ease of use for both buying and selling. For broader secondhand strategy, our Thrift and Resale Fashion hub is the place to start.

Top Online Men’s Resale Platforms

Grailed is the king of online menswear resale. Built specifically for men, it carries everything from streetwear (Supreme, Palace, Stussy) to sartorial (Thom Browne, Zegna, Canali) to workwear (Carhartt WIP, Filson, Barbour). The search and filter system is excellent, the community is knowledgeable, and the pricing reflects actual market value rather than wishful thinking. Buyer protection covers items that arrive not as described, and seller feedback histories make it easy to judge who you’re buying from.

Mens Clothing on Poshmark has built out its men’s section significantly. The negotiation system is the best feature, and paying full list price is rarely necessary. Start with an offer at 30 to 40 percent below asking, and most sellers will counter somewhere reasonable. Poshmark is strongest in the mid-range — J.Crew, Ralph Lauren, Brooks Brothers, Banana Republic — which is exactly what most guys building a wardrobe need.

SidelineSwap is a niche pick worth mentioning if you are into athletic gear. It carries secondhand sports equipment and athletic apparel from premium brands like Nike, Adidas, and Under Armour. The prices are substantially below retail, and the condition is generally good because athletic gear gets cycled out for upgrades rather than worn to destruction.

ThredUp is a weaker fit for men: it doesn’t run a men’s clothing department (its clothing is women’s and kids’, with men’s limited to shoes), so it’s mainly useful for shopping for a partner or kids. For men’s basics, the closer comparison is new budget pieces — Mens Casual Button Down Shirt on Amazon — versus secondhand Gap, J.Crew and Old Navy shirts on Poshmark and eBay, which show up at steep discounts.

In-Person Resale Shops for Men

Buffalo Exchange and Crossroads Trading are the most consistent in-person chains for men’s resale. Both buy and sell, which means the inventory is curated — they reject pieces that do not meet their quality and style standards. The result is a smaller but more reliably good selection than what you would find at a thrift chain. Expect to pay $15 to $50 per piece, which is more than Goodwill but with a much higher hit rate.

Local consignment shops are worth scouting, especially in affluent neighborhoods. The donate-and-consign patterns of wealthy areas mean that high-quality menswear shows up regularly — Canali suits, Ferragamo ties, and Allen Edmonds shoes are the kind of pieces that land in neighborhood consignment shops when previous owners simply upgrade and move on.

Tips for Getting the Best Value

Know your measurements cold. Not your size — your actual chest, shoulder, sleeve, waist, and inseam measurements in inches. Resale shopping across brands makes size labels meaningless. A 42R from one brand and a 42R from another can differ by two inches in the chest. Measurements are the only reliable way to buy secondhand clothing that fits.

Check sold listings, not active listings, to understand what something is worth. Every resale platform has a history of completed sales. A jacket listed for $150 but with comparable sold listings at $80 tells you where to start your offer. On Poshmark, tap “Filter” then “Availability” then “Sold” to see completed transactions. On Grailed, toggle the “Sold” filter in any search. On eBay, check the “Sold Items” box under the search filters. This research takes two minutes and can save you $30 to $50 on a single purchase by giving you real leverage in negotiations.

The Verdict

The men’s resale market is mature, accessible, and loaded with value. Grailed for the best menswear-specific experience, Poshmark for mid-range brands and negotiation, and local consignment shops for in-person finds are the three pillars of a solid secondhand menswear strategy. Know your measurements, shop by recent sold prices, and focus on natural-fiber pieces from known brands. The quality available secondhand consistently outperforms what retail offers at the same price point. See our Online Men’s Thrift Store guide and our Second Hand Clothes for Men breakdown for more options.

Shop the look on Amazon

Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.

Browse picks on Amazon →

FAQ

Is Grailed trustworthy for buying men’s clothing?

Yes. Grailed has buyer protection through PayPal and their own dispute resolution system. The platform has been operating since 2013 and has a strong reputation in the menswear community. Stick to sellers with established histories and positive feedback for the safest experience.

How much can I save buying men’s clothes resale?

Typically 50 to 80 percent off retail for items in good condition. Basics from mid-range brands see the steepest discounts. Designer and hype pieces hold more value but still offer 30 to 50 percent savings over retail.

Can I sell men’s clothes on resale platforms too?

Every platform listed here supports selling. Grailed and Poshmark are the easiest to list on, and both have strong buyer traffic for menswear. Photograph well, list accurate measurements, and price based on recently sold comparables to move items quickly.

How do you buy a secondhand men’s suit online that fits?

Buy a secondhand men’s suit online by measurements, not the size label, since a 42R from one brand can differ by two inches in the chest from another. Ask the seller for the jacket’s shoulder width, chest, sleeve and length, plus the trouser waist and inseam, and compare them to a suit that already fits you. Prioritize shoulder fit, because a tailor can adjust sleeves, waist and hems far more easily than shoulders.