Guides

Is Goodwill a Thrift Store? How It Works Explained

Shopper in a cream sweater flipping through jackets and knits on a donated clothing rack

Yes — Goodwill is a thrift store, and one of the largest in North America. The confusion usually comes from how Goodwill is structured, not from what it actually sells.

If you have wondered whether Goodwill counts as a “real” thrift store, the short answer is yes. Goodwill Industries International operates roughly 3,300 retail locations across the US and Canada, selling donated secondhand goods to fund job training and employment services. That is the textbook definition of a thrift store: secondhand inventory, donation-sourced, nonprofit-affiliated, charitable mission. The confusion is usually about scale (Goodwill is so big it feels more like a department store than a neighborhood thrift) or about how the organization operates financially. For the wider context on where Goodwill fits among other nonprofit chains, see our Thrift Store Chains overview.

What makes something a thrift store

A thrift store, in the conventional US definition, is a retail operation that:

  • Sells secondhand goods (apparel, housewares, furniture, books, electronics)
  • Sources inventory primarily through donations rather than consignment or purchase
  • Is typically run by a nonprofit organization with proceeds funding a charitable mission

Goodwill checks every box. Donations come from the public, they are sorted and priced at local processing centers, and the proceeds fund Goodwill’s core mission — job training, career services, and employment placement for people facing barriers to work. Our What Is a Thrift Store? How It Works and Why It Matters piece walks through the full definition in more depth.

Why some people think Goodwill is not a thrift store

A few reasons, each of which has a kernel of truth:

1. Goodwill has gotten big and corporate-looking. The modern Goodwill store — bright lights, organized by color and size, computerized POS — does not look like the dusty church-run thrift most people picture. But the model underneath is identical to any other donation-based thrift.

2. Goodwill prices have drifted upward. There is real, documented criticism that Goodwill prices are higher than they used to be, especially on branded apparel. Some regions price competitively; others reflect the upward pressure in urban markets. The price drift does not change the definition — Goodwill is still a secondhand shop — but it does affect how shoppers perceive the value.

3. Goodwill Industries pays its executives. Regional Goodwill CEOs earn six-figure salaries, which is public information in nonprofit filings. Large nonprofits typically pay competitive administrative salaries; whether this is appropriate is a legitimate debate, but it is not a structural reason Goodwill isn’t a thrift store.

4. Goodwill has an auction site. ShopGoodwill.com is a legitimate online auction platform where Goodwill regions sell higher-value donated items. It does not change the brick-and-mortar stores’ thrift status.

How Goodwill compares to other thrift chains

Goodwill is bigger than every other thrift chain in North America. By revenue, it is larger than Salvation Army’s thrift division. By store count, it exceeds Savers, Value Village, and Unique combined. The thrift experience at a typical Goodwill is closer to Salvation Army than to, say, a curated resale shop like Buffalo Exchange — full-category inventory, accepting most donations, tiered pricing based on perceived brand and condition.

For a direct chain-by-chain comparison, our Salvation Army Thrift Store anchor covers Salvation Army in depth. If you are trying to figure out whether similar-sounding retail chains count as thrift stores, our Is Ross a Thrift Store? Off-Price vs Thrift Explained and Is Burlington a Thrift Store? Off-Price vs Thrift Explained pieces answer the two most common off-price retailer confusions.

Is Goodwill a good thrift store?

Depends on the location. Goodwill is more than 150 independent regional nonprofits operating under the national Goodwill Industries brand, and stores vary enormously by region. Some Goodwills are impeccably organized with aggressive pricing; others are rougher and price inconsistently. The Goodwill Outlet (“bins”) stores — pay-by-the-pound warehouse locations — are a totally different experience, popular with resellers who dig through unsorted bins.

For evaluating any new thrift (Goodwill included), our Thrifting walks through the checklist. Before you donate, a quick note: if you are dropping off clothes, wash them first — not every shop strips and relaunders before selling. If you are buying, bring a Lint Roller And Fabric Shaver Set on Amazon for the inevitable pilled sweater you fall for.

The verdict

Goodwill is absolutely a thrift store — it is, by most measures, the largest thrift retail operation in North America. The confusion usually stems from its scale (it no longer looks like a small community shop) or from legitimate critiques of its pricing and executive compensation. Those critiques can be valid and simultaneously not change the structural answer: Goodwill sells donated secondhand goods under a nonprofit model to fund a charitable mission. That is a thrift store. If your question underneath the question is “is Goodwill a good thrift store,” the honest answer is location-dependent — some regional Goodwills are among the best thrifts in their markets, and some have priced themselves out of usefulness. Try your nearest two or three locations (they are often different management) and judge from there. For the best bin-diving experience specifically, seek out a Goodwill Outlet.

Shop the look on Amazon

Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.

Browse picks on Amazon →

FAQ

Is Goodwill a nonprofit?

Yes. Goodwill Industries International and its regional affiliates are all registered 501(c)(3) organizations.

Where does Goodwill’s money go?

Revenue funds job training, career services, and employment placement — that is Goodwill’s stated mission. Operating costs and administrative salaries come out of revenue before program spending. Check your regional Goodwill’s Form 990 on GuideStar for specific breakdowns.

Is Goodwill cheaper than other thrift stores?

Not necessarily. In many markets Goodwill prices are similar to or slightly higher than Salvation Army. For the deepest bargains, look at Goodwill Outlet (by-the-pound) locations if your region has one.

What type of store is Goodwill?

Goodwill is a nonprofit, donation-based thrift store that sells secondhand goods to fund job training, career services and employment placement. Its stores carry apparel, housewares, furniture, books and electronics, priced by brand and condition. Goodwill is more than 150 independent regional nonprofits under the Goodwill Industries brand, and some regions also run pay-by-the-pound outlet stores plus the ShopGoodwill.com online auction for higher-value donated items.


Shopping Goodwill

Best days and colour-tag sales.

Guides