Crossroads is not a thrift store and it is not a consignment shop. It is a for-profit buy-sell-trade chain that pays you on the spot for clothes it thinks it can resell, and that one fact explains almost everything people love and hate about it.
Crossroads Trading gets searched constantly by two very different people: shoppers who want name-brand secondhand clothes in a curated store, and sellers who want to know whether hauling a bag of jeans to the counter is worth the trip. This review answers both. We cover who runs the company, how the buy counter works, the cash-versus-trade-credit choice, the Sell by Mail option, and how Crossroads compares with Buffalo Exchange, Plato’s Closet and old-school consignment. If you are still mapping out the bigger picture of secondhand retail, our Thrift Store Chains hub explains where buy-sell-trade stores sit next to charity thrift and resale apps. The short version: Crossroads is a real, long-running business that does what it says. Whether it is worth your time depends on what is in your closet.
What Crossroads Trading actually is
Crossroads Trading Co. is a for-profit resale chain founded in 1991 and headquartered in Berkeley, California. At the time of writing its website lists about 38 US locations, spread across Northern and Southern California, the Pacific Northwest, Colorado, the Midwest, the East Coast and Texas. That makes it one of the more established independent names in the buy-sell-trade category, and it has been doing the same basic thing for more than three decades.
The for-profit part matters, because shoppers sometimes walk in expecting a charity thrift. Crossroads does not run on donations, and your purchase does not fund a nonprofit program the way a Goodwill or a hospice thrift does. The store buys inventory directly from the public, prices it for resale, and keeps the margin. That is not a criticism. It is simply a different deal from charity thrift, and it is why the racks look different: everything on the floor was chosen by a buyer who thought it would sell, rather than accepted because someone dropped off a bag.
The buy-sell-trade model is closest in spirit to Buffalo Exchange, which runs on a similar idea. If you want the side-by-side of how those stores differ from donation-based shops, our explainer on Consignment Store vs Thrift Store covers the three main models in plain terms.
Selling at Crossroads: how the buy counter works
Selling at Crossroads happens in two ways. The classic route is in-store: you bring clothing to the buy counter, a buyer goes through it, and they make an offer on the pieces they want. Anything they pass on goes back to you. You then choose how you want to be paid, either in cash or in trade credit to spend in the store.
The second route is Sell by Mail. Crossroads sends a prepaid UPS bag, you fill it with clothes and ship it back, and the company reviews the contents remotely. This is the better option if you do not live near one of the roughly 38 stores, or if you simply do not want to stand at a counter while someone sorts your wardrobe in front of you. The tradeoff is the same as any mail-in resale service: you are giving up the instant answer and the ability to take rejected items home on the spot. Check the current Sell by Mail terms on crossroadstrading.com before you ship, since the details of what happens to items they decline are set by the company and can change.
What Crossroads buys is driven by what it can resell quickly. Shopper and seller reviews consistently describe the buyers as selective: current, recognizable brands in clean condition move; dated mall basics, visibly worn pieces and anything stained or pilled usually come back. That selectivity is the single biggest source of frustration in online reviews. People bring in a full bag and leave with an offer on three items. That is the model working as designed, not a scam, but it helps to set expectations before you go.
What Crossroads pays: cash vs trade credit
We are not going to quote a payout percentage. Crossroads does not publish one we could verify, and figures that circulate online are secondhand and often outdated. What is consistent across seller accounts is the structure: trade credit is worth more than cash. If you were going to shop at Crossroads anyway, taking credit is the better deal. If you need money in hand, cash is the right call even though the number is lower.
The honest way to think about the payout is against your alternatives. A buy-sell-trade store pays you immediately and takes all the risk of the item not selling. A consignment shop pays you a larger share, but only after the item sells, and only if it sells. Listing the same piece yourself on a resale app can net the most, but you do the photos, the listing, the questions, the packing and the waiting. Crossroads is the fastest and least effortful route of the three, and you pay for that speed with a smaller cut. Our roundup of Where to Sell Used Clothes for Cash Near You (In-Person Options) lays out the full menu if you want to compare before you commit.
The sellers who come away happiest share a pattern. They bring a small, edited selection of current-season, in-demand brands, freshly laundered and pressed, and they treat the visit as a quick clear-out rather than a payday. A wrinkled pile pulled from the back of a closet reads as low-effort inventory to a buyer. A quick pass with a Handheld Garment Steamer on Amazon before you bag things up costs a few minutes and makes every piece look closer to what the store wants to hang on its racks.
Top-selling match on Amazon
- Powerful & Efficient: Equipped with 1000W high power, it heats up quickly in 20 seconds to generate strong…
- Portable & Lightweight: With a compact and lightweight design, it can be easily tucked into suitcases or…
- Easy Fill Water Tank: The detachable water tank is designed for effortless refilling. Simply pull it…
Buying at Crossroads: what’s on the racks
For shoppers, Crossroads sits between a charity thrift and a boutique. Because buyers pick inventory for resale, the racks skew toward recognizable, current brands and wearable condition. You will usually find more contemporary denim, outerwear, dresses and shoes than at a donation thrift, and less of the random housewares, dated suiting and mystery-brand basics that fill a typical Goodwill aisle.
Prices reflect that curation. Expect to pay more than a charity thrift and less than buying the same item new. Shopper reviews describe the value as solid on mid-tier brands and less exciting on fast fashion, where new prices are already low enough that a secondhand markup is hard to justify. The deep-discount treasure hunt that thrifters love is not really the Crossroads experience. You are paying for someone else having done the first sort.
Inventory also depends heavily on the neighborhood. A Crossroads location is stocked largely by people who live near it, so stores in different cities can feel quite different in brand mix and price level. If one location disappoints, another may suit your taste better.
Where Crossroads falls short
The recurring complaints in public reviews fall into a few buckets. Sellers say the buyers are too picky and the offers feel low. Some describe inconsistent decisions between visits or between stores, with an item turned down at one location and accepted at another. Shoppers occasionally mention pricing that seems high for the brand. None of these are signs of a dishonest company. They are the friction points of a business that decides what to buy item by item and has to resell at a profit.
There is also no charity angle, which matters to some readers. If part of the reason you thrift is that your money supports a local program, a nonprofit store will feel better than Crossroads. And because Crossroads only buys clothing it can resell, it is not a place to offload worn-out basics, which belong in a donation bin or a textile recycling program.
How Crossroads Trading compares
| Option | Model | When you get paid | Effort for the seller | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crossroads Trading | For-profit buy-sell-trade; buyers pick items to resell | On the spot, cash or trade credit (Sell by Mail after review) | Low: bring or mail a bag | Clearing current brand-name clothes fast |
| Buffalo Exchange | Buy-sell-trade with cash or trade offers | On the spot | Low | Sellers near a Buffalo store who want a second offer |
| Plato’s Closet | Buy-outright resale store | On the spot | Low | Casual, trend-led pieces |
| Traditional consignment shop | Store sells on your behalf and splits the sale | Only after the item sells | Medium: drop off, then wait | Higher-value pieces where a bigger cut is worth the wait |
The table makes the main tradeoff obvious: buy-sell-trade stores trade a lower payout for speed and certainty. Crossroads, Buffalo Exchange and Plato’s Closet all pay you on the day, and all three are selective. The practical difference between them is mostly about what each store’s buyers are looking for and which one is closest to you. Many sellers take the same bag to two of them in one afternoon, selling what the first passes on to the second. Our guides to Buffalo Exchange and What Is Plato’s Closet & How Does It Work? Complete Buyer & Seller Guide explain each store’s buying style in more detail.
Consignment is the real alternative for anything genuinely valuable. If you own a designer bag or a high-end coat, an instant offer from a buy counter is unlikely to beat a consignment split, even after the wait. For that tier of clothing, read our breakdown of Upscale Resale Shops before you hand it over to a buy-sell-trade store.
Tips for selling at Crossroads
Edit before you go. A small bag of your best, most current pieces gets a better reception than a large mixed haul, and it keeps the wait at the counter short. Launder and de-fuzz everything, check zippers and buttons, and fold neatly. Bring items that suit the season the store is about to sell into, since buyers think in terms of what will move in the next few weeks.
Decide on cash or credit before the offer arrives. If you already know you will shop the store, take the credit. If not, take the cash and do not overthink it. And treat rejections as information, not insult: a passed item tells you something about current demand, and it can go to a consignment shop, a resale app or a donation bin instead.
The verdict
Crossroads Trading is a legitimate, long-established business that does exactly what it promises: it buys clothes it can resell and pays you immediately. For sellers with a small stack of current, recognizable brands in good condition, it is one of the least painful ways to turn a closet clear-out into cash or store credit, and Sell by Mail makes it workable even if you are nowhere near a store. Sellers who expect thrift-bin generosity or consignment-level payouts will be disappointed, and most of the angry reviews come from that mismatch. For shoppers, it is a reliable middle ground: better curated than charity thrift, cheaper than new, and no good for bargain-bin hunting. Use it for speed. Use consignment for value. Donate the rest.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
Is Crossroads Trading a thrift store?
No. Crossroads Trading Co. is a for-profit buy-sell-trade chain. It buys clothing from the public and resells it, rather than taking donations and funding a charity the way nonprofit thrift stores do.
Does Crossroads pay cash for clothes?
Yes. Sellers can take an offer in cash or in trade credit to spend in the store. Trade credit is worth more than the cash offer, so it suits people who plan to shop there.
Can I sell to Crossroads without going to a store?
Yes. The Sell by Mail program sends a prepaid UPS bag that you fill and return for review. Check crossroadstrading.com for the current terms, including what happens to items they decline.
How many Crossroads Trading locations are there?
At the time of writing the company’s website lists about 38 US stores across California, the Pacific Northwest, Colorado, the Midwest, the East Coast and Texas. Use the store locator on the official site for current addresses and hours.