I waited two months for the Ayla Baggy in my size on a Net-a-Porter restock, paid $258, and have worn them through nine cold washes. The cult status is real, and so is the price.
The Citizens of Humanity Ayla Baggy is the brand’s headline cut for the 2024 to 2026 baggy revival. It sits at $258 retail, $208 to $258 across washes, and is the silhouette most editorial pages reference when they show off premium baggy denim. The fit and fabric live up to the press, with one caveat that nobody tells you in the editorial writeups. Pillar context lives in the designer women’s denim guide.
What makes the Ayla distinct
The Ayla is a high-rise baggy. That separates it from the AGOLDE Low Slung Baggy, which is genuinely low-rise, and from the Mother Tunnel Vision, which is high-rise but cleaner through the leg. Ayla sits at the intersection: high rise plus relaxed through the seat plus column-leg through the calf. The proportions read flattering on more body shapes than the lower-rise baggies because the high waist defines without cinching.
If you have worn the Citizens of Humanity barrel or the Annina trouser, the Ayla reads as the slouchier sibling. Same fabric DNA, different attitude.
Real specs and fabric
The Ayla sits at roughly 11 inches front rise, around 22 inches at the leg opening, and a 32-inch inseam in the standard length. Fabric is 100 percent cotton in the brand’s signature 12 oz weight. There is no elastane. There is no recovery. The hand is heavier than AGOLDE and lighter than R13, which is exactly where Citizens of Humanity tends to live.
I am 5’7″, true 27 waist, and the 27 fits clean at the hip with about a half-inch of give at the waist on day one that closes by hour two. The 32-inch inseam hits at the floor with a flat shoe and breaks at the foot with a low boot.
The fit reality
Ayla runs true to size in the waist and slightly slim through the thigh on the first wear. After two cold washes the cotton softens and the thigh opens. Size for the waist; do not size up for the thigh. The non-stretch fabric means whatever fit you arrive at by week three is your permanent fit.
Honest negative: the Ayla is grading-sensitive across washes. The dark indigo runs slightly larger through the seat than the medium wash. If you are between sizes, the wash you pick affects which size to order. This is the caveat editorial writeups skip.
Compared to the dupes and the field
At $258, Ayla sits at the top of the premium baggy tier short of luxury. The closest premium dupe is the AGOLDE Low Slung Baggy at $188, which runs lower at the rise and uses the same all-cotton character. The Mother Tunnel Vision at $258 matches on price and uses a similar cotton with cleaner factory finishing. Below the premium tier, Madewell’s Baggy Tapered at $128 gets you the silhouette in softer cotton. Old Navy’s Extra High-Waisted Wide Leg at $40 is the mass-market reference. Cross-shop current Ayla stock at Citizens Of Humanity Ayla Baggy Jeans on Amazon and at Citizens Of Humanity Baggy Jeans Women on Amazon.
If you are torn between the Ayla and the AGOLDE Low Slung Baggy, look at our Low Slung Baggy review for the head-to-head. If you are torn against the Mother Half Pipe, the silhouettes are different (Half Pipe is barrel, Ayla is column-baggy).
Outfits that actually work
First, fitted white tank, brown leather belt, leather Birkenstock Boston. The Ayla summer uniform. Second, cropped black knit, gold hoops, square-toe ankle boot. Cooler weather rotation. Third, oversized button-down half-tucked, white sneaker, structured tote. Saturday morning. Fourth, silk camisole, slim leather mule, gold layered necklaces. Date night.
The Ayla does not work with anything tight on the bottom on top in my opinion. A loose drape balances the slouch. A bodycon top reads costumey.
Resale data
Citizens of Humanity Ayla resells at $135 to $200 on The RealReal and Vestiaire when wash is current and size is clean. Poshmark runs $90 to $150. The cut holds resale value better than most premium baggies because the brand has not flooded the secondary market. Buy at full price and wear hard, and you will recover 50 to 65 percent of cost on a clean resale.
The verdict
Buy the Ayla if you want the editorial high-rise baggy at the premium tier and you wear non-stretch cotton well. Skip it if you prefer low-rise or if elastane is non-negotiable for your comfort. The Ayla is the rare premium denim cut where the price-to-quality math actually pencils out. Cross-shop Free People baggy, the baggy jeans guide, and the baggy womens roundup before settling.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
Does the Ayla Baggy run true to size?
True in the waist, slightly slim through the thigh on the first wear. The thigh opens after two cold washes.
What is the front rise on the Ayla?
Approximately 11 inches. It is a high-rise baggy, distinct from the lower-rise AGOLDE Low Slung Baggy.
Is the Ayla non-stretch?
Yes. 100 percent cotton, around 12 oz weight, no elastane.
Where does the Ayla go on sale?
Net-a-Porter, Shopbop, Saks, and Citizens of Humanity DTC during August and December events. Discounts run 25 to 40 percent.
