I bought the Pistola Cassie Wide Leg at Anthropologie for $138, retail price, and have washed them eight times. The fabric is lighter than premium. The fit is exactly what I expected for the money.
Pistola is the most accessible of the premium-adjacent denim brands stocked at Anthropologie, Revolve, Shopbop, and Nordstrom. The wide-leg lineup includes the Cassie ($138 to $158) and the Penny ($148 to $168). Both run mid-rise to high-rise depending on the cut. Both use cotton with around 1 to 2 percent elastane. Both sit roughly $80 to $120 below comparable AGOLDE and Mother wide-leg cuts. Pillar context is in the designer women’s denim guide.
Cassie versus Penny
The Cassie is the higher-rise of the two: 11 inches front rise, around 21 inches at the hem, full 32-inch inseam. The Penny is the slightly more relaxed cut: 10 to 10.5 inches front rise, around 22 inches at the hem, 31 to 32-inch inseam. Both read closer to AGOLDE Henson than to Mother Tunnel Vision in silhouette philosophy.
If you already wear the Pistola barrel or the Wes Barrel, the Cassie shares fabric DNA. The brand’s denim character is consistent across silhouettes.
Real specs and fabric
The Cassie sits at roughly 11 inches front rise, around 21 inches leg opening, and a 32-inch inseam. Fabric is cotton with around 1 to 2 percent elastane. The hand is lighter than AGOLDE and noticeably lighter than Mother. That is reflected in the price.
I am 5’7″ and the standard 32-inch inseam hits at the floor with a flat shoe. With a small heel, the inseam reads slightly long, just at low break.
The fit reality
The Cassie runs true to size in the waist and through the hip. The 1 to 2 percent stretch keeps the fit clean through the day. Pistola’s grading is more consistent than 7FAM and slightly less consistent than AGOLDE. If you are between sizes, size down.
Honest negative: the lighter fabric weight pills at the inner thigh by wash six. Not as quickly as Free People baggy lines, but more than premium-tier denim. Bag-laundering helps. If pilling sends you into a rage, the Pistola tier is not the right one.
Compared to the dupes and the wide-leg field
At $138, the Cassie sits at the entry of premium-adjacent wide leg. The Madewell Harlow at $128 is the closest mid-tier dupe: similar weight, similar stretch, slightly different cut. The AGOLDE Henson at $228 is the premium step up. The Mother Tunnel Vision at $258 is the slouchier premium alternative. The Free People Pamela at $128 is the boho-leaning peer at the same price tier. The mass-market dupe is Old Navy Extra High-Waisted Wide Leg at $50. Compare current Cassie stock at Pistola Wide Leg Jeans on Amazon and Pistola Cassie Wide Leg on Amazon.
If you arrived from petite searches, see the Pistola petite review for length-inclusive options. The full premium wide-leg cross-shop list also includes Citizens of Humanity Annina, Veronica Beard Carson, and the R13 Damon Pleated.
Outfits that actually work
First, fitted white tank, brown leather belt, leather Birkenstock Boston. The Cassie summer uniform. Second, cropped knit in oatmeal, gold hoops, white sneaker. Saturday morning. Third, fitted black turtleneck, structured blazer, ankle boot. Office. Fourth, ribbed tank, slim leather sandal, structured tote. Late spring.
The Cassie does work with sneakers, unlike most premium wide-leg cuts, because the slightly lighter fabric drapes more forgivingly with athletic shoe bulk.
Wash and care reality
I cold-wash the Cassie inside out and lay flat to dry. The lighter fabric weight handles wash without much bleeding after the first cycle. The 1 to 2 percent elastane recovers cleanly overnight. The fabric softens noticeably after wash three. The pilling at the inner thigh, however, sets in around wash six regardless of laundry care, which is the brand’s known weakness. The pocket lining is thinner than premium-tier and wears at the seam-edge faster, which becomes visible around wash ten.
Resale data
Pistola Cassie resale is thinner than premium-tier resale. Poshmark and Mercari run $40 to $80. The RealReal does not consistently list Pistola because the price point sits below their typical premium curation threshold. If you buy the Cassie, plan to wear rather than flip.
Where the Cassie sits in a multi-pair rotation
If your closet already has an AGOLDE or Mother wide leg in rotation, the Cassie reads as the casual second pair. The lighter fabric and slightly more relaxed fit make it the everyday wear and the premium pair the dressed-up backup. If the Cassie is your only premium-adjacent wide leg, lean toward the higher-rise variant in the lineup so the cut works across more outfit categories.
The verdict
Buy the Cassie if you want a premium-adjacent wide leg at the lowest price tier in this batch and you accept lighter fabric and inner-thigh pilling. Skip it if you wear non-stretch all-cotton denim and the AGOLDE Henson is in your budget. The Cassie is the right buy for buyers who want the silhouette without the price commitment. Cross-shop Pistola Bobbie straight, Pistola Wes Barrel, and the broader premium wide-leg field before settling.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
Do Pistola wide leg jeans run true to size?
Yes through the waist and hip. Slight grading inconsistency across washes. Size down if between.
What is the inseam on the Cassie Wide Leg?
Approximately 32 inches in standard length. Petite versions run shorter through Pistola’s petite line.
Are Pistola wide leg jeans non-stretch?
No. The Cassie and Penny use around 1 to 2 percent elastane.
Is Pistola comparable to AGOLDE?
Two tiers below in fabric quality. The cuts are similar; the cotton hand is lighter and the price is roughly 60 to 65 percent of AGOLDE retail.
