I bought the Deep Trance Boyfriend in February for $128 after a 30 percent off promo and have washed them seven times since. The fit changes more than I expected, and not always in the right direction.
Free People boyfriend jeans live in a strange middle space. They are cheaper than Mother or AGOLDE, slouchier than most premium boyfriend cuts, and built on the brand’s We the Free sub-line that runs warmer and more lived-in than the rest of the catalog. The Deep Trance Boyfriend ($128) is the headline cut. The We the Free Boyfriend ($118) is the staple. Whether they belong in your rotation depends entirely on whether you want a fashion-forward slouch or a clean tailored boyfriend, because Free People only really does the first one. For more pillar context, see our designer women’s denim guide.
The two cuts that matter
The Deep Trance is the one Free People has been pushing across editorial and influencer placements. It is a relaxed mid-rise boyfriend with a dropped-yoke back, slight taper at the ankle, and intentional whiskering at the hip and knee. The We the Free Boyfriend is the older, plainer sibling: same general silhouette, less distressing, more variation in wash.
If you already wear the Free People baggy line or the leopard barrel, the Deep Trance reads as the dressed-down cousin. Less drama, more pile of denim on a Saturday.
Real specs and fabric
The Deep Trance sits at roughly 10 inches front rise, around 16 inches at the leg opening, and a 30-inch inseam in standard length. The fabric is a cotton-elastane blend, around 98 percent cotton and 2 percent elastane. It is heavier than Madewell denim and lighter than Mother, which is exactly where the price lives.
I am 5’7″ and the standard 30 inch inseam hits me at the top of the ankle, which is the intended cuff-once-and-go length. If you are 5’10 plus and want a true mid-foot break, this cut is not for you.
The fit reality
Deep Trance runs slightly large in the waist and true through the hip. If you are between sizes, size down. The 2 percent elastane gives just enough recovery to keep the knee from bagging by 4 pm but not enough to hold a shape if you size up. The We the Free Boyfriend runs more honest to size and uses less stretch.
The honest negative: after seven washes, the right knee on my pair started to twist forward by about half an inch. Free People customer service told me this is fabric memory and to iron the seam flat. It works for two days then twists again. This does not happen on the AGOLDE Tony Vintage Boyfriend or the R13 Boy, both of which use heavier cotton with no elastane.
Compared to the dupes and the premium tier
At $128, the Free People sits cheaper than premium and pricier than mass-market. The cleanest mid-tier dupe is Madewell’s Perfect Vintage Boyfriend around $110. Same general silhouette, slightly less whiskering, similar cotton hand. The mass-market dupe is Old Navy’s Extra High-Waisted Slouchy Straight at around $40. The fit is looser, the fabric is thinner, the price is a third.
Going up market, the comparable premium cuts are the AGOLDE Tony Vintage Boyfriend ($228), the R13 Boy ($325), and the Stella McCartney boyfriend ($495). The Free People is two tiers below the AGOLDE and three below the Stella in fabric quality, and the price reflects that. Compare current options at Free People Deep Trance Boyfriend Jeans on Amazon and at We The Free Boyfriend Jeans Women on Amazon.
Outfits that actually work
First, oversized white tee tucked half in, brown leather belt, slouchy ankle boot. The Free People classic. Second, fitted ribbed tank, gold layered necklaces, leather Birkenstock Arizona. Boho without leaning costumey. Third, cropped cardigan in cream, slim ballet flat, structured shoulder bag. Office-adjacent. Fourth, oversized button-down knotted at the waist, ankle sock, white sneaker. Saturday morning.
The Deep Trance does not work with a stiff tailored blazer in my experience. The slouch on the bottom and structure on the top fight each other. A soft draped jacket is the better partner.
Resale data
Free People boyfriend jeans hold $35 to $65 on Poshmark and Depop. Resale value is thinner than premium denim because the brand restocks similar washes every season. If you buy in spring expecting to resell in fall, expect 40 to 50 percent off retail.
The verdict
The Deep Trance is the boyfriend cut you buy if you live in slouchy denim and want the brand-name version of Madewell at $20 more. Skip it if you want a clean tailored boyfriend or if you have had bad luck with elastane-blend twisting. Cross-shop 7FAM Josefina, the wider baggy boyfriend category, the Free People flare line, and the Free People wide-leg cuts before committing.
Shop the look on Amazon
Everything you need to build a secondhand-style wardrobe, delivered. We may earn a commission on purchases.
FAQ
Do Free People boyfriend jeans run true to size?
The Deep Trance runs slightly large in the waist; the We the Free Boyfriend runs true. If between sizes, size down on Deep Trance.
What is the inseam on the Deep Trance Boyfriend?
Approximately 30 inches standard, hitting at the top of the ankle on a 5’7″ wearer.
Are Free People boyfriend jeans good for tall women?
Below average. The 30-inch standard inseam is short by premium-denim standards. Look at AGOLDE or R13 if you need 32-inch options.
Are Free People boyfriend jeans worth it over Madewell?
Marginally. The whiskering and wash treatment are slightly more editorial; the fabric and hand are similar. If price is tied, pick on which silhouette you prefer.
